Opening on July 17, 1956,
High Society garnered mixed reviews, often being compared as a lesser offering to
The Philadelphia Story, a previous adaptation in 1940 of the same play starring
Cary Grant in the Crosby part,
Katharine Hepburn in the Kelly role, and
James Stewart in an
Oscar-winning turn as the reporter played in the remake by Sinatra.
Variety observed: "
High Society should spell high finance business all over. It's a solid entertainment every minute of its footage. Fortified with a strong Cole Porter score, film is a pleasant romp for cast toppers Bing Crosby, Grace Kelly and Frank Sinatra who, tactfully, get alphabetical top billing. Their impact is almost equally consistent. Although Sinatra has the top pop tune opportunities, the Crooner makes his specialties stand up and out on showmanship and delivery, and Miss Kelly impresses as the femme lead with pleasantly comedienne overtones. This is perhaps her most relaxed performance ..."
Bosley Crowther of
The New York Times described it as "flimsy as a gossip-columnist's word", missing "the snap and the crackle that its un-musical predecessor had." The movie premiered at the
Radio City Music Hall. According to
Time, in spite of its "Who's Who cast" the film is "simply not top-drawer"; a "good deal of the screenplay seems as dated today as the idle rich ... [Kelly] lacks the gawky animal energy that Katharine Hepburn brought to the 1939 play and the 1941 movie, [Crosby] saunters through the part rather sleepily, without much of the old Bing zing [, and] Sinatra plays the reporter like a dead-end kid with a typewriter." At the North American box-office,
High Society was a success. It was one of the
10 highest-grossing films of 1956 in the US and Canada earning $5,602,000, and $2,656,000 elsewhere, resulting in a profit of $1,148,000. ==Awards and nominations==