Conflicts with Jewish critics of Israel Some Jewish members and leaders of Hillels have criticized and objected to the organization's use of the motto "Wherever we stand, we stand with Israel" for "alienating Jewish students critical of Israeli policies, as well as for attaching a political ideology to an otherwise apolitical religious and cultural organization". Hillel was also accused of employing
monopolistic tactics to "assume control over the Jewish campus scene". In March 2015, the Student Board President of
Muhlenberg College's Hillel resigned over Hillel's "refusal to sponsor Open Hillel's Caroline Dorn", protesting Hillel's "refusal to allow civil rights veterans to speak at Hillel", said in her resignation: "I can't be a representative of Hillel International, an organization that I feel is limiting free speech on our campus and prohibiting academic integrity." The event was held without the sponsorship of Hillel and had an estimated 100 attendees. In 2014, some members of
Princeton University Hillel, known as the Center for Jewish Life, criticized executive director Rabbi Julie Roth for sending a mass email that encouraged Hillel members to oppose a petition by some tenured Princeton faculty members demanding the university to
divest from companies that profit from the "occupation of the West Bank by Israel." 38 Jewish Princeton students wrote an open letter accusing the group of expecting its members to oppose the petition unquestioningly. The students' letter was published in the campus newspaper,
The Daily Princetonian, also objected to the group's prohibition of member-chapters from hosting discussion with groups or individuals supporting the
BDS movement. In 2006, a
George Washington Law School student organized an on-campus rally to call for the
disinvestment from Israel. In response, the director of
George Washington University Hillel Robert Fishman claimed that the rally's organizer was deemed a terrorist by Israel, had been convicted of crimes in both Israel and the United States,
advocating for the destruction of Israel, admitting to associations with suicide bombers and had made comments about his desire to become a suicide bomber. explaining that it violated the
Hillel International Standards of Partnership due to JVP's pro-BDS stance.
Avraham Burg In November 2013,
Harvard Hillel barred
Avraham Burg, a former Speaker of the Israeli
Knesset, from speaking at Hillel due to the event's co-sponsorship by the pro-BDS Harvard Palestinian Solidarity Committee. Harvard Hillel has been accused by critics of "a naked attack on free speech."
BDS In January 2016,
Boston University Hillel hosted a public event called "All Students, All Israel Think Tank" which included sections on how to "combat BDS." The event was advertised to the entire student body and had an optional advance registration. Nine members of
Students for Justice in Palestine showed up to the event, but were removed by campus police."
Nir Barkat In April 2016, the San Francisco chapter of Hillel hosted a talk by Jerusalem Mayor
Nir Barkat at
San Francisco State University. Students opposing the Hillel accused Barkat of previously "encouraging demolitions" of Palestinian homes in East Jerusalem while protesting the event. Hillel characterized the protests as
antisemitic, which was disputed by an independent investigation.
Virginia Tech harassment allegations In September 2021, the Graduate and Professional Student Senate at
Virginia Tech proposed a resolution demanding the university to
divest from Israel. The proposers accused the Hillel at Virginia Tech of "harassing" the resolution's supporters, despite its exercise of
freedom of speech as protected by the
First Amendment of the
U.S. Constitution.
I [heart] Hamas stickers In November 2023, an independent contractor, hired by Hillel to "help quell anti-Israeli sentiment on campus" distributed stickers that read "I [heart]
Hamas" on the
University of British Columbia's Vancouver campus. The stickers included the name and logo of the UBC Social Justice Centre, a pro-Palestine student organization, on the stickers, falsely attributing the sticker to them. The stickers resulted in threats being made against racialized students associated with the Social Justice Centre, including attempts to find out where individual students live. Upon the stickers' publication on social media, conservative politicians including former
Conservative Senator Linda Frum and director of the
BC Conservative Party Angelo Isidorou condemned the Social Justice Centre and called for actions to be taken against its members.
UCLA Hillel rabbi and director Chaim Seidler-Feller was accused by journalist Rachel Neuwirth of assaulting her on the UCLA campus in October 2003. Eyewitness accounts were contradictory, with some indicating that Neuwirth did not provoke the incident, but others insinuating that she had. After over three years of litigation, Seidler-Feller reportedly provided Neuwirth with a letter of apology accepting responsibility for the alleged attack on Neuwirth in a
legal settlement to end the dispute.
The New School Hillel chapter suspension On May 1, 2026,
The New School's Hillel chapter had its funding paused by the University Student Senate (USS), following an investigation by the new Registered Student Organization (RSO) compliance committee found the chapter had "extensive ties" to international law violations. In a 35 page report, the commitee determined the chapter had "direct and material ties to international law violations," including supporting the
Oketz,
Kfir,
Golani, and Handasa units of the
Israel Defense Forces (IDF). The vote was the first instance of an American university's student government voting to pause funding for a Hillel chapter.
Reaction Hillel International CEO and President Adam Lehman said in a statement that "The New School famously sheltered Jewish intellectuals fleeing Nazi persecution — and yet its student senate voted to deprive Hillel of funding unless it severs ties with Hillel International, the world's largest and most inclusive Jewish student organization." The email was signed by University President Joel Towers, Provost and Executive Vice President for Academic Affairs Richard Kessler, and Vice Provost for Student Success and Engagement Robert Mack. The statement added "the administration is taking immediate steps to address the USS's action and ensure it acts within its actual purview, now and going forward." On May 2, 2026, Ilya Bratman, director of Leader Family Hillel at
Baruch College, which oversees The New School's Hillel chapter, said, "this is a preposterous attempt to erase Jewish Life on campus and a blatant attempt to exclude and intimidate the Jewish community at New School!," adding, "We will fight this injustice and absurdity with every tool at our disposal." == See also ==