Libretto At the age of 69, Pellegrin had a long career as an opera librettist behind him, so it was unsurprising Rameau should have approached him for his debut, especially given his authorship of
Jephté. Distant models for
Hippoyte et Aricie were
Hippolytus by
Euripides and
Phaedra by
Seneca the Younger, but the most important source was
Jean Racine's famous tragedy
Phèdre (1677). Such a classic of the
Grand Siècle would have been well known to the audience so adapting it might be seen as a deliberate provocation to the conservatives. There are several differences between
Hippolyte et Aricie and
Phèdre. Some of these are due to differences in genre between French Classical drama and
tragédie en musique. Racine observes the
Aristotelian unities of time and space: the action of his play is confined to a single location and takes place within 24 hours. On the other hand, each act in Pellegrin's libretto has a different setting. Pellegrin also provides a happy ending, at least for the lovers Hippolyte and Aricie, whereas Racine is wholly tragic; Hippolyte does not rise from the dead. Pellegrin's drama has a major change in focus: Racine's play centres on Phèdre; she is still important in Pellegrin's version, but he pays much more attention to Thésée. For instance, the entirety of the second act is devoted to Thésée's visit to the Underworld. Graham Sadler writes: He goes on to describe Theseus as "one of the most moving and monumental characterizations in Baroque opera."
Music The overture begins conventionally enough, in traditionally noble Lullian style, but the technical complexity of the ensuing
fugal movement must have disturbed conservative critics worried that Rameau's music would be overly (learned). Since the death of
Louis XIV the allegorical prologue no longer had any social or political function. Instead, Pellegrin uses it to foreshadow the action of the main opera by showing Destiny ordering Diana and Cupid to unite their efforts to ensure a happy outcome for Hippolyte and Aricie's love. The music of the prologue creates a "light and airy" atmosphere. The two
gavottes in the soon became immensely popular. The first act introduces the lovers Hippolyte and Aricie, as well as the jealous Phèdre. It begins with Aricie's aria "Temple sacré, séjour tranquille", with its solemn and "religious cast". There follows an extensive dialogue in
recitative between Aricie and Hippolyte. Rameau's recitative is like Lully's in that it respects the prosody of the words, but it is more (song-like) and has more ornamentation, with wider intervals to increase expressivity. Phèdre then gives vent to her jealousy in the aria "Périsse la vaine puissance". The High Priestess of Diana arrives and sings a highly
contrapuntal aria with contributions from the chorus. The (thunder) which ensues is in the French tradition of the musical depiction of meteorological phenomena. The most famous earlier example was in Marais's
Sémélé (1709). Rameau's music is much more intense, containing "
Vivaldian tremolos and rapid scale figures." Pellegrin situated the second act in the Underworld, following the example of Lully's
Alceste (1671),
Isis (1674), and
Proserpine (1680), as well as later works by
Desmarets,
Marais, and
Destouches.
Isis, which had been revived on 14 December 1732, was particularly important for Pellegrin as it had a trio for the Fates. The dark colour of this act is enhanced by the use of solely male voices. There are lively and rhythmically inventive dances for the demons contrasted with Thésée's moving invocations to save the life of his friend Pirithous in music in which "the expression of the sentiment is cut down, as it were, to the bone". The act concludes with the famous and controversial second "Trio des Parques", omitted from the premiere because the Opéra's singers and instrumentalists found it too hard to play. It makes use of
enharmony, a technique Rameau believed was ideal for "inspiring dread and horror". At the beginning of act 3, Phèdre implores Venus for mercy in the aria "Cruelle mère des amours" which Girdlestone praises as a "magnificent solo" in spite of its "terribly flat" words. There follows a violent confrontation between Phèdre and Hippolyte then a scene in which Phèdre's confidante Oenone suggests to the king that Hippolyte has attempted to seduce his wife. In a scene of "grim irony", Thésée is forced to suppress his rage while he watches a
divertissement of sailors thanking Neptune for his safe return home. The entertainment consists of two
rigaudons, two danced airs and the chorus "Que ce rivage rétentisse". The festivities over, Thésée finally has the chance to call on his father Neptune to punish Hippolyte in the invocation "Puissant maître des flots", which Girdlestone regarded as one of the finest solos of the 18th century with its contrast between the violin melody and the slower bass. Act 4 opens with Hippolyte's monologue "Ah, faut-il qu'en un jour", which looks forward to similarly "elegiac" arias in Rameau's later operas, for example "Lieux désolés" in
Les Boréades. The
divertissement in the middle of the act celebrates the hunt, with extensive use of horns. The finale is devoted to Hippolyte's confrontation with the sea monster, depicted in stormy music in which the flutes represent blasts of wind. It ends with Phèdre's great lament, which Sylvie Bouissou describes as "one of the finest pages of French Baroque opera". The final act is split into two . In the first, Thésée expresses his remorse for his treatment of Hippolyte and recounts Phèdre's suicide. In the words of Cuthbert Girdlestone, "it is a passionate, despairing
scena with no fixed form". The scene shifts as Aricie is transported to be reunited with the resurrected Hippolyte in a beautiful rural landscape. This allowed Rameau to paint the scene using the techniques of pastoral music, including a
musette (a type of bagpipe). He also displayed his orchestral skill in a
chaconne, another feature of many of his later operas. The composer made a concession to popular taste by inserting the "Nightingale aria" () before the final
gavottes. It is an example of an , the French term for a long in the Italian style, with the aim of showing off the singer's technical prowess. This particular specimen has no connection with the action of the drama, something Rameau would change with he wrote later, such as "Que ce séjour est agréable" and "Aux langueurs d'Apollon Daphné se refusa" in
Platée. ==Roles==