From the movement's beginnings, with its roots in
Wesleyan theology, Methodism has distinguished itself as a religious movement strongly tied to social issues. As father of the movement,
John Wesley injected much of his own social philosophy into the movement as a whole. Wesley's personal social philosophy was characterized by "an instructive reluctance to criticize existing institutions [which] was overborne by indignation at certain abuses which cried out for rectification." The Methodist Church's responses to injustices in society are embodiments of the Wesleyan traditions of mercy and justice. At the end of the 19th- and beginning of the 20th-centuries, the Methodist Church responded strongly to what it regarded as social ills (e.g., gambling, use of intoxicating beverages, etc.) with attention to the Methodist doctrines of sanctification and perfection through Christ. In the United States, today's
United Methodist Church continues to embody Methodist traditions in their response to social needs through the
General Board of Church and Society and the General Board of Global Ministries. In the United States, the United Methodist Church is the second-largest sponsor of
Boy Scout units, with 11,078 chartered units, representing over 370,000 youth members; by way of contrast, the
LDS Church, which sponsors a total of 37,882 units – over three times as many – can boast a total youth membership of slightly over 420,000, only a 13.5% increase over the UMC's total.
Attitudes toward slavery Like most other national organizations, the Methodist Church experienced tensions and rifts over the
slavery dispute. Both sides of the argument used the doctrines of the movement and scriptural evidence to support their case. The initial statement of the Methodist position on slavery was delivered in the Conference minutes from the annual conference in 1780. After a comprehensive statement of the varied reasons slavery goes against "the laws of God, man, and nature", the Conference answered in the affirmative to the question, "do we pass our disapprobation on all our friends who keep slaves and advise their freedom?" This position was put into action in 1783. Preachers from the Baltimore Conference were required, under threat of suspension, to free their slaves. By 1784, similar requirements were made of Methodists as a whole, laity and clergy alike. The negative reaction to this requirement was so strong that it had to be abandoned, but the rule was kept in the
Book of Discipline. As slavery disputes intensified in the 19th century, there emerged two doctrines within the Methodist Church. Churches in the South were primarily proslavery, while northern churches started
antislavery movements. The
apologia of the Southern churches was largely based in
Old Testament scriptures, which often represent slavery as a part of the natural order of things.
New Testament writings were sometimes used to support the case for slavery as well. Some of the writings of
Paul, especially in
Ephesians, instruct slaves to remain obedient to their masters. Southern ideology also argued that slavery was beneficial for slaves, as well as their owners, saying that they were offered protections from many ills because of their slavery. The antislavery movement in northern churches strengthened and solidified in response to the pro-slavery apologia of Southern churches.
Education of young people , 1946 The Methodist church has always been strongly oriented towards the religious lives of the young. In 1848, the General Conference stated, "when the Church has collected...a great population born within [her] bosom, she cannot fulfill her high mission unless she takes measure to prevent this population from being withdrawn from under her care in the period of its youth." The first two American bishops of the Methodist Church,
Thomas Coke and Francis Asbury, opened a preparatory school in
Abingdon, Maryland in 1787. The school was a strict environment, with seven hours a day devoted to study. The venture ended when a fire destroyed the building in which the school was housed. In the 1870s, there was a broad movement toward incorporating Sunday schools into the doctrines of churches as a way to take ownership of the Christian education of children. This was the first great
interdenominational movement the United States had ever seen. Methodists invested heavily in the cause of Christian education because of their emphasis on the child's right to and ability to "respond to divine influences from the beginning." Beginning after World War II, the Methodist churches in the United States continued developing, at a much greater pace, ministries on Universities, Colleges, Junior Colleges and other higher education institutions, on campuses of both church-owned and state schools throughout the United States and Canada, and to a lesser degree in Australia, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. Methodism boasts the largest number of higher education ministries, including teaching positions, of any Protestant denomination in the world in close competition with the
Southern Baptist Convention. This emphasis is, in part, a reflection of the Methodist movement's earliest roots in
The Oxford Holy Club, founded by
John Wesley, his brother Charles,
George Whitefield and others as a response to what they saw as the pervasive permissiveness and debauchery of Oxford University, and specifically
Lincoln College when they attended. It is from the Holy Club that the earliest Methodist societies were formed and spread. Methodist Churches have long emphasized the importance of confirmation as a critical stage in the religious education of young people. In many Methodist congregations, confirmation programs span months of instruction in Wesleyan theology, church history, doctrine, and disciplines, often culminating in a worship service with the laying on of hands and vows. Because confirmation is tied to the church's investment in youth, congregations often view it as a stabilizing factor in retaining adolescents in church life, helping bridge the gap from childhood religious instruction to adult discipleship.
Temperance movement The
temperance movement was the social concern which most broadly captured the interest and enthusiasm of the Methodist Church. The movement was strongly tied to John Wesley's theology and social principles. Wesley's abhorrence of alcohol use was taken up by American Methodists, many of whom were active and prominent leaders within the movement. The temperance movement appealed strongly to the Methodist doctrines of
sanctification and
Christian perfection. The Methodist presentation of sanctification includes the understanding that justification before God comes through faith. Therefore, those who believe are made new in Christ. The believer's response to this sanctification then is to uphold God's word in the world. A large part of this, especially in the late-19th century, was "to be their brother's keepers, or [...] their brother's brothers." Because of this sense of duty toward the other members of the church, many Methodists were personally temperate out of a hope that their restraint would give strength to their brothers. The Methodist stance against drinking was strongly stated in the Book of Discipline. Initially, the issue taken was limited to distilled liquors, but quickly evolved into
teetotalism and Methodists were commonly known to abstain from all alcoholic beverages. In 1880, the general conference included in the Discipline a broad statement which included, "Temperance is a Christian virtue, Scripturally enjoined." Due to the temperate stance of the church, the practice of
Eucharist was altered — to this day, Methodist churches most commonly use grape juice symbolically during
Communion rather than wine. The Methodist church distinguished itself from many other denominations in their beliefs about state control of alcohol. Where many other denominations, including Roman Catholics, Protestant Episcopalians,
Lutherans, and
Unitarians, believed that the ill-effects of liquor should be controlled by self-discipline and individual restraint, Methodists believed that it was the duty of the government to enforce restrictions on the use of alcohol. In 1904, the Board of Temperance was created by the General Conference to help push the Temperance agenda. The women of the Methodist Church were strongly mobilized by the temperance movement. In 1879, a Methodist woman,
Frances E. Willard, was voted to the presidency of the
Women's Christian Temperance Union, an organization that was founded in December 1873, and was characterized by heavy Methodist participation. To this day, the Women's Division of the General Board of Global Missions holds property on
Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, which was built using funds provided by laypeople. Women of the church were responsible for 70% of the $650,000 it cost to construct the building in 1922. The building was intended to serve as the Methodist Church's social reform presence of the Hill. The Board of Temperance, Prohibition and Public Morals was especially prominent within the building.
Varied stances on homosexuality Among Methodist denominations in the United States, the majority view homosexuality as sinful, including the
African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church,
Allegheny Wesleyan Methodist Connection,
Bible Methodist Connection of Churches,
Free Methodist Church,
Global Methodist Church,
Holiness Methodist Church,
Methodist Protestant Church,
Primitive Methodist Church, and
Southern Methodist Church. The
United Methodist Church, on the other hand, now performs same-sex marriages and ordains LGBT individuals as clergy. The United Methodist Church delegates met in St. Louis on February 26, 2019, and voted 438 to 384 to maintain its policies defining marriage as a covenant between one man and one woman and barring "self-avowed practicing homosexuals" from serving as clergy. The plan made it easier to enforce penalties for violating the teaching, which is part of the church's
Book of Discipline. However, modernist bishops in certain parts of the United Methodist Church were not enforcing the
Book of Discipline. As a result, over 25% of congregations in the United States disaffiliated from the United Methodist Church in order to preserve the traditional definition of marriage and ordination. The majority of these traditionalist United Methodist Churches have joined the
Global Methodist Church which was formed in May 2022, though other traditional United Methodist congregations have joined the
Free Methodist Church,
Congregational Methodist Church, or
Association of Independent Methodists, among other Methodist denominations aligned with the
holiness movement. Following the exodus of traditionalist United Methodist congregations from the denomination, in May 2024, the General Conference of The United Methodist Church convened in Charlotte, NC, and delegates voted to remove language defining homosexuality as sinful, along with restrictions on the ordination and marriage of LGBTQIA+ individuals from the Book of Discipline, the church's book of governance. Furthermore, the delegation voted on social principles that affirm the rights and sacred worth of LGBTQIA+ people. == References ==