John Rudge took over the management reins at Vale Park in December 1983, after the sacking of John McGrath following the club's form upon Vale's promotion to the
Third Division. Rudge said that 'we cannot change things overnight', though it did spark 'an amazing transformation of form' to oversee four consecutive home wins. The gap from safety was closed from nine to four points, and by March, he had 'achieved mission impossible' as the club escaped the relegation zone. However, a poor end to the season saw the club relegation in 23rd place. Positive signs for the future included a £50,601 profit and the rise to prominence of young striker
Mark Bright. Yet Bright left in the summer, moving to
Leicester City for £33,000. Top scorer
Eamonn O'Keefe also requested a transfer but did not get one. Rudge steadied the ship, slashing the wage bill by £20,000. A young
Robbie Earle began to show his promise, though it was veteran
Alistair Brown who was the season's top scorer, with 21 strikes. Considering Rudge's rebuilding effort with the squad, a mid-table finish was acceptable. In May 1985, young Welshman
Andy Jones was purchased from
Rhyl for £3,000. He was soon joined by £12,000 defender
John Williams and numerous others. Vale were promoted back to the third tier in
1985–86, finishing in fourth place, losing just once at Vale Park. they went on an 18-match unbeaten run during the season, building their record largely on a solid defence. Jones and Earle scored 18 and 17 goals respectively. The only downside was the finances, as a loss of £79,474 was recorded, partly due to promotion bonus payouts. In the summer of 1986, new signings included
Ipswich Town's reserve goalkeeper
Mark Grew on a free,
Aston Villa midfielder
Ray Walker for £12,000,
Sheffield United winger
Paul Smith for £10,000 and
Walsall striker
Richard O'Kelly for £6,000. Rudge also turned down the management position at Preston North End. He also attempted to bring a young
Steve Bull to Vale Park. After an unconvincing start to
1986–87, Rudge sold John Williams to
Bournemouth for £30,000 and brought in
Bob Hazell from
Reading on a free. This helped transform the club's defence, while Andy Jones' fantastic record of 37 goals helped win the Vale a
twelfth-place finish. The only worrying sign was a £53,373 loss, increasing the club's debt to £363,878. A major change occurred before the start of the
1987–88 season, as chairman Jim Lloyd stood down and was replaced by hard-nosed businessman
Bill Bell. Ten-year man
Russell Bromage went to
Bristol City in exchange for £25,000 and
Lawrie Pearson, also
Jon Bowden went to
Wrexham for £12,500. Coming in was striker
Darren Beckford for £15,000. Going into the season, Paul Smith went to
Lincoln City for £40,000 before Andy Jones was sold for a then-club-record fee of £350,000 to
Charlton Athletic. £35,000 of this went towards new full-back
Simon Mills. The campaign was boosted by a 'famous' 2–1 victory over top-flight Tottenham Hotspur in the fourth round of the FA Cup. The cup run and sale of Jones had helped to pull in a record £410,239 profit. A boost for
1988–89 came with the sale of an unused
training ground at Cobridge for £164,800. Halfway through the season, veteran
Phil Sproson was advised to retire following a serious knee injury; to replace him, defender
Dean Glover was signed from
Middlesbrough for a club-record £200,000. The club finished third, failing to gain automatic promotion because of their worse
goal difference. However, they found success in the
play-offs, defeating
Bristol Rovers in
the play-offs 2–1 on aggregate. Back in the Second Division for the first time in over twenty years, Rudge strengthened the side with £150,000 signing
Neil Aspin from Leeds United, £125,000 striker
Nicky Cross from
Leicester City and veteran campaigner
Ian Miller on a free. The
1989–90 saw many improvements to Vale Park, as on the pitch, the team did well to establish themselves in the division. They also triumphed in the FA Cup, putting three past
Derby County's
Peter Shilton in a third round replay victory. However, in the next round 'Villa went on a rampage', as they 'outclassed' the Vale with a 6–0 victory. They finished eleventh in the league, and the supporters were given much to cheer about as rivals Stoke City were relegated to the third tier, leaving Vale as 'the top team in
the Potteries' for only the second time in their history. Only one change was made to the squad in preparation for the
1990–91 campaign: Irishman
Derek Swan coming in from
Bohemians for £15,000 on a recommendation. The club considered building a new ground at
Festival Park, but Bill Bell was 'frightened to death by the cost' and the idea was scrapped. The club finished in 15th place, with Darren Beckford once again the top scorer with 23 goals. They then went into a slump, leading to their relegation on the final day of the
1991–92 league campaign. In
1992–93, Vale narrowly missed out on promotion as runners-up to
Reading when
Bolton Wanderers pipped them on the final day. Vale then lost in the play-off final to
West Bromwich Albion. Vale were able to bounce back with Rudge's next two bargain buys becoming important players.
Ian Taylor, whom Vale had signed for £15,000 from non-League
Moor Green, and Dutch import
Robin van der Laan (signed for £80,000) came to the fore. With Martin Foyle back fit and experienced
Bernie Slaven up front, Vale surged to second place, confirming promotion on the final day with a 3–1 win at Brighton's
Goldstone Ground in front of 6,000 travelling fans. Vale also notched another
FA Cup scalp, beating then–
Premiership side
Southampton 1–0 at Vale Park in a third-round replay. Taylor became Rudge's first £1,000,000 sale when
Sheffield Wednesday invested in the midfielder. The money was spent on bringing
Steve Guppy and
Gareth Griffiths to the club during the
1994–95 campaign. Vale finished 17th in 1994–95, avoiding relegation by ten points, and again despite the pre-season sale of van der Laan, who
Derby bought for £475,000.
Jon McCarthy and
Lee Mills also joined before the
1995–96 season began. During the 1995–96 season, Vale struggled to find their form. Ten games into the league season, they had recorded only one win (in the local derby against
Stoke) and were struggling near the bottom of the table. Early home form was also the worst for years, and it took the Valiants until 2 December to finally notch a win at Vale Park, when
Martin Foyle scored to beat Huddersfield Town 1–0. A 5–1 defeat at
Ipswich on New Year's Day saw Vale slip to second from bottom, with just five wins all season, but the FA Cup was again to prove the tonic. The draw had done Vale no favours, with a trip to promotion-chasing
Crystal Palace, but a goalless draw brought the tie back to Vale Park. Vale eventually won the tie on a freezing January night, with Ray Walker scoring the winner in
extra time to seal a 4–3 win and set up a trip to cup-holders
Everton in the fourth round. In the tie with Everton, Vale twice came from behind at
Goodison Park to draw 2–2, with
Ian Bogie scoring from virtually the last kick of the match. The replay saw Vale Park full to witness Vale win 2–1, with
Jon McCarthy netting the winner. The victory saw Vale enter the fifth round, where they would play Leeds United away. Leeds were then a top-ten Premiership side. The match at
Elland Road took place on a Tuesday, thanks to various cancellations due to inclement weather. The game finished goalless, and the tie went to a replay in Burslem. The Valiants' cup exploits were to come to an end as Leeds won the replay 2–1, with
Gary McAllister scoring twice in the closing stages despite Vale leading 1–0 at
half-time through
Tony Naylor. However, Vale's cup exploits were to earn them the
FA's Giantkillers award for the
1995–96 season. The cup run seemed to inspire Vale to do better things in the league, with five wins in a row pushing them up to twelfth as the season drew to a close. Vale also had some success in the
Anglo-Italian Cup, as they qualified for the final at
Wembley, in the competition's final season. Vale secured a 5–3 win at Italian side
Perugia in which Lee Mills netted a
hat-trick. The English semi-final draw pitted Vale away to
Ipswich Town, to whom they had already lost 5–1.
Tony Naylor scored a hat-trick as Vale recorded a 4–2 win at
Portman Road, the first victory in their history at the ground. A 3–1 victory in the second leg of the English final at Vale Park against West Brom confirmed a 4–2
aggregate success and a game against Italian winners
Genoa in the final. The Italians ran out 5–2 winners, with
Martin Foyle netting both Vale goals. Again, Vale made a slow start to the
1996–97 campaign, with only two wins from their opening ten league games. They enjoyed some success in the
League Cup, however, beating local rivals
Crewe Alexandra 5–1 at their
Gresty Road home. A protest against chairman Bill Bell after a poor home defeat to Crystal Palace seemed to see an upturn in the Valiants' performances. A second win at Wolves'
Molineux ground (1–0), in two seasons, was followed by a mixed period. In December they achieved three wins on the bounce, against ex-Premiership sides
Charlton 3–1 at
The Valley, 6–1 at home to
Norwich City and concluding in a single-goal
Boxing Day success at
Manchester City in front of more than 30,000. Despite the sale of
Steve Guppy to
Leicester City for £800,000, Vale's form remained steady from then on, until five wins from six, from mid-March to mid-April, put them in with a chance of making the play-offs and, ultimately, a place in the Premiership. However, with three games remaining, Vale were to lose to Stoke City before
Wolves came away from Vale Park with a 2–1 victory to end their hopes. Vale's final finishing position of eighth was their highest in the pyramid since 1931, when they had finished fifth in the old Second Division. The eighth-placed finish was to be the height of Vale's powers under John Rudge, and the following season,
1997–98, saw a more familiar mid-table and, eventually, relegation battle. Another FA Cup tie was to see Vale hold eventual winners
Arsenal to a goalless draw at
Highbury and 1–1 at Vale Park (
Wayne Corden equalising a
Dennis Bergkamp goal) before the Gunners eventually prevailed 4–3 on penalties, despite
Lee Dixon missing their opening kick. After three straight defeats, Vale found themselves in deep relegation trouble going into the final match at Huddersfield. Goals from
Martin Foyle,
Jan Jansson (two) and
Lee Mills saw Vale claim a 4–0 win and an escape at the expense of Manchester City and Stoke City.
1998–99 saw Port Vale fare a little better, with an early League Cup defeat to
Chester City setting the tone. After 16 years as Port Vale manager, John Rudge was sacked in January 1999 after one of Vale's most successful eras. ==1999–2011: Valiant 2001 and two administrations==