The terms for the new position were drawn up in
London on 22 August 1721. Requirements for the professor were not very sectarian, although Hollis made a requirement of character: "That he should be a man of solid learning in divinity, of sound, or orthodox principles, one well gifted to teach, of a sober and pious life, and of a grave conversation." Traditionally, the chair's occupant has the right to graze a cow on the
Harvard Yard, but until 2009 none but the first two Hollis professors had done so. In 2009, upon his retirement, theologian
Harvey Cox restored the tradition and chose Faith, a
Jersey cow belonging to the Farm School in
Athol, Massachusetts. Although Hollis was a
Baptist, he had enough faith in the liberal and tolerant atmosphere at Harvard to endow the chair and allow the president and faculty of the university to appoint theologians to the chair, with the condition "that none be refused on account of his belief and practice of adult baptism." Hollis's "sound and orthodox principles" initially meant
Congregationalist or
Calvinist. The chair's first occupant,
Edward Michael Wigglesworth (c. 1693–1765), had to swear allegiance to the
Medulla Theologiae, a Calvinist theological manual by
William Ames. Proponents of the Unitarian faction pointed out that it would be impossible to find a man orthodox enough for the 1720s in the early nineteenth century; "orthodox" they interpreted as following "the general sentiment of the country." In the 1830s, Harvard found itself in financial trouble and at the same time was moving away from the teaching of religion.
Josiah Quincy III, then-president of Harvard, refused to nominate a successor for Henry Ware, and the post was left unoccupied a second time. which had been formed in 1816. ==Chairholders and denomination==