1732-1825 In the early years of the church, pew-holders included
Benjamin Church,
Caleb Davis, and Benjamin West. A fire in 1787 destroyed the church building. Architect
Charles Bulfinch designed the replacement in 1788. In 1810–1811, a brick building replaced Bulfinch's wood structure. "The wooden age yields to the brick; comfort now aspires to elegance." The old Bulfinch building "was purchased by the Union Religious Society of
Braintree and
Weymouth, ... taken down piece by piece, floated on a raft to Braintree and rebuilt on Quincy Ave near Commercial St. next to the railroad tracks. The church design was slightly altered and a new bell, forged by Paul Revere, was placed in the clock tower. First services were held in the church in November 1810."
1825-1887 By 1825, some of the congregation sought to create another church to alleviate overcrowding, and so established the South Congregational Society. In 1883-1884 the church congregation erected a new building in the
Back Bay area of Boston, on
Newbury Street at Exeter Street. It was designed by architect George Meacham. Ministers included
Edward Everett Hale. In 1887 the New Hollis Street Church congregation joined the South Congregational Society, which in 1925 merged with the
First Church of Boston. The old Hollis Street building was sold, and later the site became the
Hollis Street Theatre. ==Ministers==