Gay Straight Alliance In 2007, a student-led initiative to create a Gay Straight Alliance club to address bullying was denied by school administration. Subsequent school board meetings to discuss the GSA were met by anti-LGBT protesters and media attention. After receiving guidance from the
ACLU warning that restricting the club may violate the federal
Equal Access Act, the school board voted 5–2 in favor of allowing the GSA club to operate.
Mascot In January 2020, students created a petition asking the school board to change the school's mascot and logo, arguing that the Princess Hononegah and generic Native American iconography reinforces racist stereotypes. In response, another petition was created in support of retaining the mascot. Citing the student protests at Hononegah, State Rep.
Maurice West introduced bill HB4783 to the Illinois General Assembly in March 2020 which aimed to introduce requirements that schools must meet in order to use Native American imagery. The bill passed the School Curriculum and Policies Committee in a 13–8 vote, but remains
sine die since January 13, 2021.
Lawsuit In October 2024, a federal lawsuit was filed against Hononegah High School and several district leaders, including Principal Chad Dougherty, Athletic Director Andrew Walters, and members of the football coaching staff. The lawsuit, brought by a student referred to as "John Doe," alleges that the administration mishandled retaliation against him following his parents' report of eligibility issues within the football team. After the Illinois High School Association (IHSA) placed Hononegah on probation and required the forfeiture of a game due to an oversight, Doe claims he faced severe bullying, harassment, and demotion on the team. The lawsuit argues that school officials failed to investigate or protect him, leading to emotional distress and the loss of college athletic opportunities. Hononegah's administration has denied any wrongdoing and vowed to cooperate with the legal process. ==Notable alumni==