Annunciation (ca. 1500) from a Netherlandish Book of Hours. In this example
Gideon's fleece is worked in as well, and the altar at the rear has
Aaron's rod that miraculously flowered in the centre. Both are
types for the Annunciation. The
hortus conclusus was one of a number of depictions of the Virgin in the late Middle Ages developed to be more informal and intimate than the traditional hieratic enthroned Virgin adopted from Byzantine icons, or the
Coronation of the Virgin. The subject began as a specific metaphor for the
Annunciation, but tended to develop into a relaxed
sacra conversatione, with several figures beside the Virgin seated, and less specific associations. Germany and the Netherlands in the 15th century saw the peak popularity of this depiction of the Virgin, usually with Child, and very often a crowd of angels, saints and donors, in the garden; the garden by itself, to represent the Virgin, was much rarer. Often walls or
trellises close off the sides and rear, or it may be shown as open, except for raised banks, to a landscape beyond. Sometimes, as with a
Gerard David's
The Virgin and Child with Saints and Donor (below) the garden is very fully depicted; at other times, as in
engravings by
Martin Schongauer, only a wattle fence and a few sprigs of grass serve to identify the theme. Italian painters typically also keep plants to a minimum, and do not have grass benches. A sub-variety of the theme was the German "Madonna of the Roses", sometimes attempted in sculptured
altarpieces. The image was rare in Orthodox
icons, but there are at least some Russian examples. One type of depiction, not usually compatible with correct perspective, concentrates on showing the whole wall and several garden structures or features that symbolize the mystery of Christ's conception, mostly derived from the
Song of Songs or other Biblical passages as interpreted by theological writers. These may include one or more temple or church-like buildings, an
Ivory Tower (SS 7.4), an open-air altar with
Aaron's rod flowering, surrounded by the bare rods of the other tribes, a gatehouse "tower of David, hung with shields" (SS 7.4), with the gate closed, the
Ark of the Covenant, a well (often covered), a fountain, and the morning sun above (SS 6.10). This type of depiction usually shows the Annunciation, although sometimes the child Jesus is held by Mary. A rather rare, late 15th century, variant of this depiction was to combine the Annunciation in the
hortus conclusus with the
Hunt of the Unicorn and
Virgin and Unicorn, so popular in secular art. The unicorn already functioned as a symbol of the
Incarnation and whether this meaning is intended in many
prima facie secular depictions can be a difficult matter of scholarly interpretation. There is no such ambiguity in the scenes where the archangel
Gabriel is shown blowing a horn, as hounds chase the unicorn into the Virgin's arms, and a little Christ Child descends on rays of light from God the Father. The
Council of Trent finally banned this somewhat over-elaborated, if charming, depiction, partly on the grounds of realism, as no one now believed the unicorn to be a real animal. In the 16th century the subject of the
hortus conclusus drifts into the open air
Sacra Conversazione and the Madonnas in a landscape of
Giovanni Bellini,
Albrecht Dürer and
Raphael, where it is hard to say if an allusion is intended. An exhibition of later medieval visual representations of
hortus inclusus was mounted at
Dumbarton Oaks, Washington DC; the exhibition drew a distinction between "garden representations as thematic reinforcements and those that seemingly treat the garden as a subject in itself"; in reviewing it Timothy Husband, warned against uncritical interpretation of the refined detail in manuscript illuminations' "seemingly objective representation". "Late medieval garden imagery, by subjugating direct observation to symbolic or allegorical intention, reflects more a state of mind than reality," if a disjunct can be detected where the objects of the world shimmered with pregnant allegorical meaning. South Netherlandish illuminations and painting appear to document the "turf benches, fountains, raised beds, 'estrade' trees, potted plants, walkways, enclosing walls,
trellises,
wattle fences and
bowers" familiar to contemporary viewers, but assembled into an illusion of reality. Image:Gentile da Fabriano, Thronende Maria und Kind, Hl. Nikolaus, Hl. Katharina und Stifter, 1400-10, Gemäldegalerie Berlin.jpg|
Gentile da Fabriano Image:Fra Angelico — Annalena Altarpiece.jpg|
Fra Angelico Image:Gerard David - The Virgin and Child with Saints and Donor - Google Art Project.jpg|
Gerard David File:Madonna w ogrodzie Mistycznym.jpg|Style of
Dieric Bouts File:Museo di castelvecchio, michelino di besozzo, madonna del roseto.JPG|Italian miniature, c. 1435 File:Vierge a la rose dans un jardin clos.jpg|Early
woodcut, c. 1460, hand-coloured Image:Stefan_Lochner_Madonna_im_Rosenhag.jpg|
Stefan Lochner Image:Bartolomé Bermejo - Retablo della vergine di Montserrat.jpg|
Bartolomé Bermejo,
Virgen de Montserrat altarpiece, 1485 Image:Triptych of the Virgin and Child with Saints.jpg|Cologne, ca. 1520 file:Juan de Juanes - Inmaculada Concepción.JPG|
Juan de Juanes, after 1530 File:Virgin-saints-garden-1418.jpg|Woodcut dated 1418, but probably 1450s ==Modern cultural references==