The New Republic Evan Hughes wrote that Knausgård's followers feel like he writes about them, that the book is "like opening someone else's diary and finding your own secrets". In a review of
Book 2: A Man in Love in
The New York Times, Leland de la Durantaye called the
My Struggle series "breathtakingly good" and compared it to
Marcel Proust’s
In Search of Lost Time. In a review of
Book 3: Boyhood Island in the
Times Literary Supplement, Thomas Meaney reflected on the differences between Proust and Knausgård, and wrote about the philosophy behind the
Min Kamp books. Joshua Rothman notes in his article in
The New Yorker that "In previous volumes, we’ve watched a younger Karl Ove struggle to absorb his father’s dark energies. In the new volume, his dad is no longer abusive." However, in an interview with Andrew O’Hagan, Knausgård has said that writing
My Struggle has not helped him in conquering his fear of his father. Frenchculture.org website noted that, even though Knausgård was called the "Norwegian Proust", the first volume sold very few copies in France, probably because the strong French tradition of
autofiction makes the book look less original than it appears in the US. Liesl Schillinger further explains the uniqueness in Knausgård's writing for even his own culture, stating in her
Wall Street Journal profile piece: :"No other Norwegian writer had dared such full disclosure. France has a tradition of autobiographical fiction, and memoir is common in the United States but not in Scandinavia."
Lorin Stein observes: :"Norwegians say that the confessional instinct is so culturally alien to them that it was, in a funny way, useful to him." As Knausgaard sees it, "There was a threshold for writing about real people, and it was shockingly open. That was very important to me, it gave me courage." Knausgård has been criticized over the way he exposes other people in the book. A girlfriend he had for four years, anonymized under the name «Gunvor» in the fifth volume, said to the newspaper
Bergens Tidende: "It was as if he said: Now I'm going to punch you in the face. I know it's going to hurt, and I will drive you to the hospital afterwards. But I'm going to do it anyway." ==Theatrical adaptation==