On November 14, 1860, he married Elvira Tuttle Gould (1840–1926), the daughter of
Joseph Paxton Gould (1804–1880) and Eloise Elvira Tuttle (1808–1860), in
Newark, New Jersey. Together, they were the parents of: • Frederick Vail Brokaw (1866–1891), a student at
Princeton who drowned while trying save a girl. • Grace Elvira Brokaw (1867–1868), who died young. •
Isaac Irving Brokaw (1871–1939), a noted skater who was married to Lucile Nave (d. 1937). • Elvira Brokaw (1872–1958), who married Carl Aage Vilhelm Frederick von Fischer-Hansen (1868–1950), a Danish nobleman, in 1896. They divorced in 1911, and in 1914, she married William McNair (1871-1947), also an attorney. • Howard Crosby Brokaw (1875–1960), who married Edna Goadby Loew (1882–1960) in 1903. They had three daughters. • Ernest Brokaw (1879–1881), who also died young. •
George Tuttle Brokaw (1879–1935), who married
Clare Boothe (1903–1987), in 1923. They divorced in 1929. In 1931, he married
Frances Ford Seymour (1908–1950). He died in
Elberon, New Jersey, on September 29, 1913. The Brokaw estate, which was left in a Trust, The entire estate was left to his wife and living children.
Descendants Through his son Irving, he was the grandfather of Lucile Brokaw, who married
James Duane Pell Bishop, a grandson of
Heber R. Bishop, in 1936, Barbara Lucile Brokaw, who married Leonard Jarvis Cushing, and Louise Elvira "Mimi" Brokaw, who married painter Richard Derby Tucker. They divorced in 1925, After Fairchild's death in 1940, she married Vicomte Jacques de Sibour (1896–1979), the nephew of
Jules Henri de Sibour, in 1949. De Sibour had previously been married to Violette Selfridge, daughter of
Harry Gordon Selfridge, with whom he had a son, Jacques de Sibour, Jr. (1928–2005) before their divorce in 1949. Through his son George and daughter-in-law
Clare Boothe Luce, he was the grandfather of Ann Clare Brokaw (1924–1944), who was killed in an automobile accident while a senior at
Stanford University, and Frances de Villers "Pan" Brokaw (1931–2008), a half-sister of
Jane and
Peter Fonda, who later married Francesco Corrias, and became a painter. ==Notes==