The 1886 death of Tennessee federal judge
John Baxter created a vacancy for President Cleveland to fill on the
circuit court for the
Sixth Circuit. Cleveland asked his friend Jackson, who was still serving in the Senate, to recommend potential replacements, but the President ignored his advice and instead offered the seat to him. The ruling in
Greene rejected a Sherman Act indictment against whiskey producers on the basis that the defendants were not preventing other firms from entering the whiskey market. Jackson's narrow interpretation of the Act set the stage for later consequential antitrust cases, including
United States v. E. C. Knight Co. (1895), and it continued to influence
interstate commerce law for half a century. In other cases, Jackson took a broader view of constitutional provisions. His 1893 ruling in
United States v. Patrick interpreted the
Civil Rights Act of 1870 expansively. The defendants in
Patrick, who were residents of Tennessee, had been charged with killing several federal officers while they were searching for an illegal
still. A lower federal court threw out the indictments, holding the officers were not exercising any legally protected civil right while they were carrying out their duties. Jackson rejected these arguments. In his view, federal officers have a constitutionally protected right "of accepting the public employment, and engaging in the administration of its functions". On that basis, Jackson concluded the prosecution under the Civil Rights Act could go forward since the officers' civil rights had been violated. Some Southerners denounced the ruling, objecting that it expanded the scope of an already loathed law. Jackson's decision also showed that his stances were sufficiently moderate to coalesce with the Republican agenda. == Supreme Court nomination ==