Following his death, Lane's will bequeathed his collection to London, but an unwitnessed later
codicil bequeathed it to Dublin. Having possession, London's
National Gallery did not recognise the codicil. Altering this legal reality became the life's work of Professor
Thomas Bodkin. At the request of Lane's aunt,
Lady Gregory, the leader of the Irish Government
W.T. Cosgrave unsuccessfully approached
Ramsay MacDonald on the matter in 1929. Then, in 1938, the present-day solution came from the British side, during the
House of Lords debates on the
Eire (Confirmation of Agreements) Act 1938.
Lord Strabolgi put forward a suggestion from
Sir Robert Witt: "..that these pictures should alternate between London and Dublin. We have had them in London for a considerable number of years, and it might now be the turn of the Dublin Galleries to have them for a number of years... Legally, the holders have a very strong case, but we are so wealthy in our treasures, while Ireland is so comparatively poor..."
Lord Marley added: "My Lords, perhaps I might say one word in support of what my noble friend Lord Strabolgi has said because Sir Hugh Lane was a cousin of mine, and I do know he was very anxious, even before this codicil was made, that the pictures should go to Dublin. I hope that something will be done in support of what my noble friend has said." When
John A. Costello became
Taoiseach in 1948, he initiated further negotiations with the UK government. Support in London was maintained in 1953 by
Lord Moyne, who said in Parliament: ".. I would urge on Her Majesty's Government to include in it a provision for the return of the thirty-six, or so, pictures which were collected by the late Sir Hugh Lane as a basis for a modern collection for Ireland ...." These interventions eventually led on to a compromise agreement in 1959, announced by Taoiseach
Seán Lemass, whereby half of the Lane Bequest would be lent and shown in Dublin every five years. In his announcement of the agreement, Lemass thanked the then-retired Thomas Bodkin for his persistence, helped by Lord Moyne and
Lord Pakenham. In 1993, the agreement was changed so that 31 of the 39 paintings would stay in Ireland. The remaining 8 were divided into 2 groups so that 4 would be lent for 6 years at a time to Dublin. These 8 include works by
Manet,
Monet,
Pissarro,
Renoir,
Morisot,
Vuillard and
Degas. In 2008, the National Gallery in London arranged for the entire collection to be on display in Dublin together for the first time. There was a switch in May 2013 for a six-year period. ==References==