Tetraneuris herbacea is known from just a few natural and introduced populations. In Ontario there are about 20 populations all located at the shores of
Lake Huron on the
Bruce Peninsula and
Manitoulin Island. where it can be found at the Lakeside Daisy State Nature Preserve, a protected area named in its honor. There is an introduced population on
Kelleys Island, Ohio, as well. In Illinois, naturally occurring lakeside daisies were last seen in 1981, and today the daisies occurring there are introduced populations in nature preserves. In Michigan there is one population in
Mackinac County on the
Upper Peninsula, which may or may not be naturally occurring.
Tetraneuris herbacea occurs on
alvars, a type of limestone pavement with little plant cover. These rocky outcrops have thin, alkaline soils and are quite dry in the dry seasons, making them inhospitable for many other plant species, so the lakeside daisy grows in unshaded full sun. In Michigan the habitat is based on
tufa and
marl, different types of limestone substrate.
Tetraneuris herbacea is threatened by the loss of its habitat. The limestone plain where it grows naturally in Ohio, the largest population within the bounds of the United States, is privately owned by a quarrying company that mines the rock. The spoils of the quarry are dumped directly on top of clumps of the flower. Recreational activity such as the use of
off-road vehicles damages the habitat. In some areas supporting the plant, lack of a natural
fire regime allows
ecological succession to occur in the nearly barren habitat, so that woody vegetation grows and blocks sunlight. The plant is limited to a rare type of habitat and its populations are small. Because each plant requires pollen from an unrelated individual in order to reproduce, small, widely spaced populations make reproduction difficult. ==Recovery efforts==