"Hyperballad" was highly acclaimed by contemporary music critics. Mike Diver of
BBC Music said "Hyper-Ballad – single four of six taken from this 11-tracker – is similarly striking [to "
Army of Me"], and remains among the very finest songs in Björk’s canon [...] perfectly is an indelibly excellent example of music meeting art. It’s a benchmark of successful audio-visual synergy." Steve Baltin from
Cash Box named it "Pick of the Week", noting that it "glistens with the dazzling light heartedness that characterizes the critically-hailed
Post collection." He added, "With
disco undercurrents beneath the strong pop grooves, "Hyper-Ballad" is a delightful track that all fans of quality music will enjoy. [...] Don't be surprised if this song becomes a club hit." Chuck Campbell from
Knoxville News Sentinel found that the "humming, low-slung" track "is much darker as Bjork reveals an early morning ritual of throwing objects from a cliff and imagines taking the plunge herself."
James Hyman from
Music Week's
RM Dance Update rated it 5 stars out of five, adding, "From day one, Bjork embraced dance culture, realising its importance in running parallel to the commercial release. 'Hyperballad' is icing on that cake". Another editor,
James Hamilton, noted its "winsome caterwauling quirkiness". Also Eric Henderson from
Slant Magazine was favorable, saying, "Without missing a beat, Björk puts herself into the role of fragile suicidist on "Hyper-Ballad," as she throws tchotchkes over a cliff to approximate the nature of her own plunge. A phenomenal journey, the track begins with lightly shuffling drum n' bass before expanding into an immense house groove."
Drowned In Sound listed it at number #8 on their top ten Björk singles.
XFM Radio listed it at number 686 on their The XFM Top 1,000 Songs Of All Time.
NME listed the song as the 69th best song of the 1990s, stating that "'Hyperballad' was an earnest attempt to try and make old love alive once more. She said it was about the art of "not forgetting about yourself" in a relationship and this was reflected in the music which altered from gentle
folktronica to drum and bass-tinted
acid house."
Diffuser.fm described the song as "lush, sweeping cinematic
synth-pop." "Hyperballad" received the most votes from Björk fans in the survey for her
Greatest Hits album's tracklist. In September 2022,
Pitchfork named the second-best track of the decade on their "Top 200 Tracks of the 90s" list, behind
Mariah Carey's "
Fantasy (Bad Boy Remix)". ==Music video==