Shortly after its release, Madonna was called "the most important dance artist" by a number of media outlets,
You Can Dance is one of the first sets of remixes to be conceived as a full-length album.
Matthew Rettenmund, author of
Encyclopedia Madonnica (1995), complimented rather releasing a
greatest-hits album, her first
compilation was a "groundbreaking
remix album". The entire concept of copying, repeating, pasting and playing was still in its "infancy" when Madonna released this project. Biographer David James commented that "Madonna broke fresh ground". Steffanee Wang from
Nylon slightly noted its influence on
Club Future Nostalgia by
Dua Lipa. Despite this, the album was well received by fans. Other retrospective assessments specifically praised its impact as a remix album on
record charts. Rob Copsey from the
Official Charts Company stated that it "set the bar for how it should be done". Commercially, Easlea wrote that while the record missed out on the US top 10, it still managed to sell more than a million copies—"no mean feat" for a material that had "largely been previously released elsewhere". Its worldwide results led to it becoming the best-selling remix album for nearly ten years until the release of
Blood on the Dance Floor: HIStory in the Mix by Michael Jackson. The album was described as "groundbreaking" by Sal Cinquemani of
Slant and O'Brien, the latter of whom compared its impact to the likes of
Like a Prayer and
Ray of Light. Music critic
Robert Christgau called both
You Can Dance and
The Immaculate Collection "stunning" records, while the staff of
Rolling Stone called both compilations "perfect Madonna" albums.
You Can Dance made appearances on a number of year-end and best-of lists by publications such as
Cash Box,
Los Angeles Times and
The Village Voice. Upon release, the record was chosen as "album of the week" by
Music & Media, issued on November 28, 1987. The same publication named it "The Dance Record of the Year". Lucinda Prince of the Australian website Cool Accident listed the compilation as one of the "Best 5 Pop Remix Albums". ==Track listing==