I Created Disco received mixed reviews from music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an
average score of 59, based on 17 reviews. Other notable reviews including
The Guardian were more critical, awarding the album one out of five stars, saying "
I Created Disco is witless and forever tripping over its own feet", and also criticised Harris's use of "two plodding instrumentals", saying that they "are bad enough, but on most tracks he chants repetitive lyrics so stupid they feel like an insult to the listener". Meanwhile, Lou Thomas from the
BBC was considerably more favourable of the album, saying Harris had "exquisitely tailored a calm, considered rumination on life’s great upheavals". They also praised Harris's "good sense of humour", and argued he ought to have had a sense of humour as a result of his claim of creating disco, highlighting that disco had in fact been created a significantly long time before Harris was even born. Additionally, they urged the public to "buy everything other than the album", and to subsequently "leave
I Created Disco to collect dust in the bargain bin, or, better still, the bins out the back of
HMV". ==Track listing==