I Decided was met with generally positive reviews. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from professional publications, the album received an
average score of 67, based on 13 reviews. Andy Belt of
Consequence said, "
I Decided. is a fresh statement that proves Big Sean is continuing to evolve". Matthew Strauss of
Pitchfork said, "While he has become incrementally more skilled over the years, not much else has changed. Throughout
I Decided., Sean conflates the passing of time with growth and progress. Nothing on
I Decided., however, suggests that he has gained perspective worth sharing or to which he should devote a whole album". Writing for
Rolling Stone, Brittany Spanos concluded: "As always, his earnestness is believable. Every moment he counts his blessings – like on the casually catchy single "Bounce Back" – you root for him. He embraces his underdog status, especially since he is most often pitted against and working with rap's biggest personalities, like Kanye West,
Drake, and
Kendrick Lamar. More often than not, however, he gets swallowed by the larger-than-life brands and presences of those he surrounds himself with, like
Eminem who steals Sean's thunder with the quality, agility and fire of his guest verse on "No Favors"."
Year-end lists ==Commercial performance==