The song received favorable reviews from music critics.
Nekesa Mumbi Moody from
Associated Press said it "sound decent with her pipes".
Billboard constated that it is "a song that has most-added stamped all over it," writing further, "Written by the ultimate pop/R&B scribe of the 1990s,
Diane Warren, this gorgeous ballad will take fans old and new to that sacred territory that Whitney established back in the years of classics like "
Saving All My Love for You" and "
All the Man That I Need". But make no mistake; the Houston of today is a fully seasoned, well-traveled diva, leaving the wannabes in scattered remains with this spine-chilling performance. You'll be throwing your hands in the air over the wisdom she's gained in this tale of the strong woman who's breaking bad with her lessons about heartbreak. Producer/arranger
David Foster, meanwhile, puts forth all that he's learned in the past two decades with a forceful instrumental package that borrows from his days of commandeering the horns-heavy Chicago through its comeback in the early 1980s. The three together—Houston, Warren, and Foster—simply can't miss in this stellar effort that brings together the best of their talents". Sonia Murray from
Cox News Service viewed the song as a "by-the-numbers big ballad". Henrik Bæk from Danish
Gaffa noted it as a "typical Whitney ballad". Chuck Campbell from
Knoxville News Sentinel described it as a "classy David Foster-produced" song, and added that Houston is "predictably stately". Christopher Tkaczyk from
The Michigan Daily said in his review of
My Love Is Your Love, that the song a "heart-racing R&B track".
Sun-Sentinel picked the song as the "one truly satisfying song" on the album, noting it as "an unassuming ballad". ==Release and chart performance==