"Presence, Dear" has seen critical acclaim since its release. Stewart Mason of
AllMusic wrote, "It's one of the group's early highlights, a sweet little power pop love song that features a brilliantly starry-eyed lyric set to an addictive jangly guitar riff. The missing link between
Big Star's
#1 Record and
the dB's Stands for Decibels, '(I'm Always Touched By Your) Presence, Dear' pulls off the difficult trick of being dryly ironic and utterly sincere at the same moment."
The Rolling Stone Album Guide called the song a "catchy single" that "taps into Harry's emotional reserves."
GQ ranked the song as Blondie's second best, writing, "If you ever doubted Blondie's ability to be funny, intelligent, culty and yet bubblegum, it's here in the lines of this song:'' 'We could navigate together, psychic frequencies / Coming into contact with outer entities / We could entertain each one with our theosophies.
The Daily Telegraph'' ranked it as one of the band's ten best songs, praising Harry's "glacial" vocals and describing the melody as "so insistent, you might need an exorcist to get it out of your head."
New Times Broward-Palm Beach named the song as one of Blondie's five most underrated, noting, "Harry made its sweet ode to infatuation convincing." ==Cover versions==