There is controversy about the authorship of the song.
Jerry Allison has stated that Buddy Holly was the actual author of the song. William Ruhlmann noted: The song is credited to Joe B. Mauldin, Holly's bass player; Norman Petty, his producer; and Nikki Sullivan, his sometime rhythm guitarist (who was not heard on the recording). There have long been questions about the songwriting credits assigned to the original songs Holly recorded, and Jerry Allison, his drummer, has gone on record stating that "I'm Gonna Love You Too" actually was written primarily by Holly, with Allison composing the bridge. Certainly the song sounds characteristic of the man who wrote "That'll Be the Day." It is another up-tempo number with an infectious tune and boastful lyrics that only thinly veil heartbreak. Of the song's credited authors, two (Mauldin and Sullivan) were members of Holly's band
The Crickets; the third, Petty, was Holly's first manager and also his recording engineer. Holly included the song on his
self-titled second album. It was released as a single on
Coral Records, but failed to crack the
Billboard Hot 100. In
Canada, the b-side "Listen To Me" reached #38. Holly continued to sell regionally in the upper midwest USA after his death and when rereleased, "I'm Gonna Love You Too" was a substantial 'regional' hit in Minneapolis and surrounding markets in 1964. When the song was recorded an actual cricket was in the studio. As the song is ending and fading out, you can hear the cricket chirp a couple of times. ==Blondie version==