Detroit-based rapper
Eminem stated that when he first heard "Ice Ice Baby," "I felt like I didn't want to rap anymore. I was so mad, because he was making it real hard for me." After audiences began to view Van Winkle as a novelty act and a pop star rather than a legitimate rapper, his popularity began to decline. Van Winkle lost some credibility among hip hop fans, but later began to regain some success, attracting a new audience outside of the mainstream audience that had formerly accepted him and then rejected him. According to
Rolling Stone, the "Ice Ice Baby"–"Under Pressure" controversy is a landmark music copyright case, since it "sparked discussion about the punitive actions taken in plagiarism cases". The magazine's Jordan Runtagh added: "Though [Vanilla Ice] paid the price, some argue that isn't enough to make up for the potential credibility lost by Queen and David Bowie, who are now linked to him through a collaboration they had no choice in joining." A live version of the song appeared on the album
Extremely Live. "Ice Ice Baby" was rerecorded in a
nu metal version titled "Too Cold". Originally intended to be released as a
hidden track or B-side, "Too Cold" was featured on Van Winkle's 1998 album
Hard to Swallow, and received radio play in some markets. In 2000, a remix titled "Ice Ice Baby 2001" was released in Europe as a single, with a newly produced music video. The remix generated new international interest in Van Winkle's music. "Ice Ice Baby" was awarded one of
BMI's Pop Awards in 1992, honoring the songwriters, composers and music publishers of the song. In November 2011,
MTV Dance ranked the song No. 71 in their list of "The 100 Biggest 90's Dance Anthems of All Time". In 2019,
Billboard magazine listed it at No. 108 in their ranking of "
Billboards Top Songs of the '90s".
VH1 and
Blender ranked "Ice Ice Baby" fifth on its list of the "50 Most Awesomely Bad Songs Ever". It was also given the distinction by the
Houston Press as being the worst song ever to emanate from
Texas. In 1999, the song's music video was "retired" on the MTV special
25 Lame, in which Van Winkle himself appeared to destroy the video's master tape. Given a baseball bat, Van Winkle ended up destroying the show's set. However, in December 2007, VH1 ranked the song in 29th place of their 100 Greatest Songs of the 90's. In 1991,
Alvin and the Chipmunks released a cover version entitled "Ice Ice Alvin" for their album
The Chipmunks Rock the House.
"Weird Al" Yankovic included the chorus as the final song in "
Polka Your Eyes Out", the polka medley from his 1992 album
Off the Deep End. In 2004, the song was featured in the film
13 Going on 30. In 2010, the song was featured in the
Glee episode "
Bad Reputation" as performed by
Will Schuester (
Matthew Morrison). In 2012, several references to the song were made in the film
''That's My Boy'', where Van Winkle appeared as himself – protagonist Donny Berger (
Adam Sandler), an old friend of Van Winkle, asks him for money, claiming he should be "loaded" with the royalties he receives from the song; however, Van Winkle tells him that "Queen took 50 percent, Suge took the other 60 percent, I fucking owe money when that shit gets played, man!" Later on, Donny and Van Winkle drive in Van Winkle's
Ford Mustang 5.0, a reference to the car he drove in the music video (but not the same car), then listen to the song on Van Winkle's
Walkman as they run. ==Charts==