National rankings In 2016 the
U.S. News & World Report High School Rankings listed seven IDEA college preparatory schools, three of which reported graduate rates ranging from 98 to 100% and four of which had no rates listed. College readiness percentages ranged from 54% to 86% with no data available for one. Their Texas state rankings ranged from 15th to 67th with no data on one of them. Six of the schools received gold medal rankings.
Jay Mathews commented on the ranking in the
Post: "Even more startling is the appearance of six public charter high schools in some of the poorest parts of Texas among the top 50 schools on our list, which I have produced for
The Post (and previously for
Newsweek) for 18 years. Those six schools, and a seventh that ranks No. 106, are all part of the Idea (sic) Public Schools charter network." In the 2014
U.S. News & World Report high school rankings, there were 3 IDEA schools listed; the IDEA college prep school in Donna ranked 30 out of all public high schools in the United States and 5th in the state of Texas. In 2022, the Jay Mathews
Challenge Index placed IDEA McAllen College Prep (CP) as the best school in the United States of America, with IDEA Pharr CP, IDEA San Juan CP, and IDEA Frontier CP placing in the top ten of the ranking.
Awards and recognition In 2015 the US Department of Education included IDEA as one of its "Bright Spots" in Latino education, as part of the celebration of the 25th anniversary of the
White House Initiative on Educational Excellence for Hispanics. In 2015
Children at Risk, a children's advocacy group in Houston, published a report evaluating data on charter schools in Texas that concluded: "Some charters, including YES Prep, KIPP, Idea Public Schools, Texas Preparatory Network, and Uplift Education are taking disadvantaged students to new heights of academic success, achieving what nobody thought possible. These high-performing charters excel in the education of Texas children, and do so in spite of serving a greater percentage of economically-disadvantaged children than the state average." In 2016 IDEA,
YES Prep Public Schools, and
Success Academy were named as the top three finalists for the annual Broad Prize for Charter Schools; IDEA had been a finalist in 2014 and 2015 as well.
Criticism and controversy On May 25, 2011, over 40 sensitive emails were leaked to local businesses and education leaders which mentioned the lack of potential that teachers had to be promoted into a higher position, such as a leadership role. The leaked emails were also sent to state charter officials and other IDEA staff which contained talks about expansion to other cities such as San Antonio and Austin, a bias towards Teach For America corps members and criticism involving an administrator in the Pharr-San Juan-Alamo district. In regards to preference for Teach For America members, Tom Torkelson said that he would place a "20 year veteran" if he or she could produce "expected student success results." Speaking about the administrator incident, Torkelson said that he was "frustrated" and used "some very choice words" at the moment, but has mentioned that the partnership with PSJA has been "going better than ever." The district has been criticized for selecting students based on academic performance. Dr. Ed Fuller, a professor at
Pennsylvania State University, has said that IDEA schools do not enroll "underserved" students. Antonio Limon, a San Benito school superintendent, criticized the district for "cherry picking" its students. Limon claimed that IDEA picked higher performing students when holding lotteries for admission. Torkelson has denied these claims, stating that schools host "transparent, public lotteries." Limon, however, said that even though lotteries are hosted, the district keeps the "best" students, while taking out the lower performing ones.
AlterNet, a progressive news outlet and Independent Media Institute project, criticized IDEA for eliminating "
critical thinking" in the district's curriculum, placing board members from banking organizations to generate profit for the school and taking taxpayer money to create expansion. The source has commented that IDEA board members belong to organizations such as
JPMorgan Chase,
Wells Fargo and the
International Bank of Commerce. IDEA's organization status was also criticized for taking "public subsidies" to continue operating. Although the school often "boasts" that it has a near 100% rate of its graduates going to college, ==See also==