Bosley Crowther’s review of
If I’m Lucky in the
New York Times is extremely negative. He describes the plot as an absurd and ridiculous fantasy, in which a singer runs for governor to further his own career and that of his musician friends, while exposing a political conspiracy. Crowther finds the story so implausible that even the Marx Brothers' humor wouldn’t have saved it, even if it had been performed in a more exaggerated manner. He criticizes the actors, such as Perry Como, Vivian Blaine, and Carmen Miranda, arguing they lack the qualifications for their roles and that their performances are inconsistent. The songs are also deemed mediocre, and the film as a whole is described as dreary and dull. Edwin Schallert of the
Los Angeles Times partly agrees with Crowther, stating that despite
If I’m Lucky’s attempts to present a plausible story, the film ends up being “totally absurd”. Nelson Bell of the
Washington Post describes the movie as an attempt at offering "unreflective, ephemeral fun" without depth or substance. Other critics go further, dismissing the plot as merely an excuse to string together musical numbers, with little connection or narrative logic. In 2008, when
If I’m Lucky was re-released on DVD as part of the "20th Century Fox Marquee Musicals" collection, the
New York Times noted that in films like
Doll Face and
If I’m Lucky, Carmen Miranda played supporting roles. The paper questioned how, in the context of the "new realism" that dominated postwar cinema, there could be room for such entirely unreal characters as "
The Lady in the Tutti Frutti Hat" (a reference to Miranda's character in
The Gang’s All Here). == Home media ==