Reviews If I Survive You was released to wide acclaim. In a universally positive review, Katy Waldman at
The New Yorker said that Escoffery's "fiction is marked by ingenuity [...] The book feels thrillingly free". Waldman called out Escoffery's adept sense of humor, often expressed in what she called the "comedy of infighting", and applauded his portrayal of "the disorienting effects of race as they fall".
NPR's
Maureen Corrigan felt that the ending of one of the short stories, "Splashdown", and its
sink or swim spirit favorably compared to the classic novel
Moby-Dick. She also highlighted Escoffery's writing about the effects of race in the United States, whether due to explicit racism, the effects of the
Great Recession, or in the aftermath of
Hurricane Andrew. Michael Ferry at
BookTrib lauded Escoffery's technical skill, noting that his perspective shifts between
first, second, and third person, along with his tense shifts between
past, present, and future, could have been distracting if done by a "less-skilled writer". Instead, Ferry continued, "Escoffery uses each transition with purpose. The reader is given a multitude of angles and distances from which to view each character and their environment. A strong connection is created with the subject, conflict and emotion become more intense, and the setting gains additional layers of texture."
The Guardians reviewer Ian Williams wrote out similar sentiments, and added praise for the unusual use of second person, which they thought cemented the "estrangement Trelawny feels from himself" and for the sense of empathy it fostered between the reader and main character. Williams additionally highlighted Escoffery's "interracial sensitivity", writing that his "courage to move beyond the politeness that silences meaningful conversations on race" brought on moments where Williams "wanted to snap my fingers, like at a
poetry slam." In a
starred review,
Kirkus succinctly called
If I Survive You "a fine debut that looks at the complexities of cultural identity with humor, savvy, and a rich sense of place."
Awards and honors Time and
The New York Times Book Review included
If I Survive You in their 100 top books of 2022.
Booklist listed it as a 2022 "
Booklist Editors' Choice" for adult books, as well as their 2023 list of the best historical fiction books by debut authors. having made the cut from a thirteen-strong longlist. Escoffery made the short list alongside another author's debut novel,
Chetna Maroo's
Western Lane. The Booker Prize judges called
If I Survive You "an astonishingly assured debut novel, lauded by the panel for its clarity, variety and fizzing prose. As the stories move back and forth through geography and time, we are confronted by the immigrants' eternal questions: who am I now and where do I belong?" == References ==