The album received positive to mixed critical reception.
Billboard believed that there's "Very excellent programming material here for easy listening stations, especially 'If You Ever Leave Me' and Jack Jones' versions of rock hits 'The Letter' and 'Goin' Out of My Head." They noted that "'Pretty' is a catchy little crowd pleaser, and Jones also does a winning 'By the Time I Get to Phoenix.'" On the other hand,
The Belfast Telegraph was disappointed by the LP, believing that it "too many mediocre" tracks.
Record World said that "Jones includes his recent single with other choice cuts," noting the Paich arrangements.
Cashbox magazine stated that "Jack Jones chants eleven pop ditties, creating a rich, mellow mood on such top efforts". The magazine believed that the "artist has a full-bodied, lyrical voice, and he employs it to good advantage throughout the album. The Jones boy should see a good deal of sales action with this quality LP."
The Encyclopedia of Popular Music rated the album three stars as well. == Chart performance ==