Critical response Review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes reports that 78% out of 122 professional critics gave the film a positive review, and an average rating of 7.11/10, with the site consensus stating that "
In a Better World is a sumptuous melodrama that tackles some rather difficult existential and human themes." On
Metacritic the film has a score of 65 out of 100 based on reviews from 29 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews". Kim Skotte called the film a "powerful and captivating drama" in
Politiken. Out of the four collaborations between Jensen and Bier, he considered
In a Better World to be the one most similar to Jensen's solo films and compared the combination of biblical themes and high entertainment value to Jensen's 2005 film ''
Adam's Apples''. Skotte also praised the acting performances: "Mighty Mikael Persbrandt shows that he is Scandinavia's most charismatic actor right now. Trine Dyrholm's scenes are fewer, but in a split second she can dramatise the canvas to make the throat lace itself. Also Ulrich Thomsen is good as grief-stricken single father. With her successful directing of the two boys Markus Rygaard and William Jøhnk Nielsen, Bier adds a new chapter to her already extensive resumé of top tuned skills." Peter Nielsen of
Dagbladet Information called
In a Better World "in all ways a successful film", and although there "is no doubt that Susanne Bier can tell a good story", he was not entirely convinced: "She can seduce, and she can push the completely correct emotional buttons, so that mothers' as well as fathers' hearts are struck, but she doesn't earnestly drill her probe into the meat."
Roger Ebert rated the film 2½ stars out of 4, writing that while he admired Bier's previous films
Things We Lost in the Fire and both the
Danish and
American versions of
Brothers, he felt that "here her method is too foregrounded. The African events in particular don't fit organically into the rest of the film, playing more like a contrived contrast." However, he also remarked, "The story of the boys works well (they're both good actors), and their fathers are well-drawn and seen with sympathy .... There are two strong stories here, in Africa and Denmark. Either could have made a film. Intercut in this way, they seem too much like self-conscious parables. No doubt the film's noble intentions appealed to the academy voters, but this seems to me the weakest of this year's five nominees."
Accolades On 19 January 2011, it made the shortlist for
Best Foreign Language Film and on 25 January, it was selected as one of the final five nominees and won as the Danish entry for the
Best Foreign Language Film at the
83rd Academy Awards. The film also won for Best Foreign Language Film at the
68th Golden Globe Awards. Additionally, it won: •
Rome International Film Festival 2010: • Marc'Aurelio Audience Award for Best Film • Marc'Aurelio Grand Jury Award •
Sevilla Festival de Cine 2010: • Best Director • Best Screenplay •
Tallinn Tarta, Black Nights Film Festival 2010: • Best Male Actor •
Thessaloniki International Film Festival 2010: • Creative Excellence Award •
European Film Awards • Best Director ==See also==