In a contemporary review, Steve Jones of
USA Today called
In My Lifetime "a rock-solid set with both street and pop appeal". indicating a "likable effort consumers attuned to its overriding aesthetic or individual vision may well enjoy". He named "(Always Be My) Sunshine" and "Real Niggaz" as highlights while calling Jay-Z "arrogant yet diffident, ruthless yet cute—a scary original". Chris Norris of
Spin said Jay-Z's raps are often "in search of meaty ideas or distinctive charm—skills without pleasure", and was also critical of the production. "Without one sure, guiding vision," Norris wrote, "the
Combs blueprint comes off as either mundane or embarrassing".
AllMusic editor John Bush wrote in a retrospective review, "Though the productions are just a bit flashier and more commercial than on his debut, Jay-Z remained the tough street rapper, and even improved a bit on his flow". According to Bush, he "struts the line between
project poet and up-and-coming player" while balancing "both personas with the best rapping heard in the rap game since the deaths of
2Pac and
Notorious B.I.G.". ==Track listing==