In Secret received mixed reviews. On review aggregation website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a 41% approval rating, with an average score of 5.30/10, based on reviews from 87 critics. The consensus states: "Although it benefits from a strong cast,
In Secrets stars can't totally compensate for the movie's sodden pacing and overly familiar story." Despite mixed reviews, Lange's performance has received critical acclaim. David Lee Dallas from
Slant Magazine called Lange's character's "latent severity dangerous and surprising." Michael O'Sullivan from
The Washington Post noted that "Subtlety may not be this film's strong suit, but it certainly is Lange's." Jessica Herdon of the
Associated Press added that Lange "[goes] from agonized to helpless, so poignantly that your heart breaks for her." Odie Henderson praised Lange on her ability to "...[find] the perfect line of lunacy to toe, which
In Secret requires for her character's arc..." Emma Myers from
Film Comment described her ability to "[maintain] a looming presence that shifts from despicable to sympathetic and back again."
USA Today described her work as her "...most fully dimensional performance."
Variety mentioned that Lange "...relishes what becomes the most dramatically potent role." Joshua Rothkopf from
Time Out New York praised the chemistry between Olsen and Isaac. ==References==