Editors at AnyDecentMusic? scored this release a 7.3 out of 10, aggregating 17 reviews.
BeatRoute's Jennie Orton gave the album a positive review calling it a fitting end to the band and writing that they, "ha[ve] done a stellar job of embracing the sadness of the material, as if to give themselves and the rest of us a place to put the grief about O'Riordan's pain and how it ultimately got the best of her". In
The Irish Times, Eamon Sweeney gave the album four out of five stars, calling it "remarkably uplifting". Asya Draganova gave the recording three out of five stars, writing for
The Arts Desk that it's, "a tribute to the friendship and the shared path of her fellow band members Noel Hogan, Mike Hogan, Fergal Lawler—illustrating well how the four had grown together with their audience over thirty or so years." Writing for
NME, Mark Beaumont gave the album three out of five stars, specifically praising O'Riordan's vocals. Charis McGowan of
Clash summed up her review, "An album pieced together by a band in mourning, with the sweet sadness of O'Riordan‘s voice layered over, makes it cruder, rawer yet ultimately more truthful and hard-hitting, evoking the charged vulnerability of their very first releases" and gave the release eight out of 10. ==Chart performance==