The
Parliament of the United Kingdom's Joint Committee on
Human Rights has voiced concerns about certain aspects of the Act, as have the
Law Society of England and Wales.
Amnesty International has asked members of the British judiciary not to serve on any inquiry held under the Act, as they contend that "any inquiry would be controlled by the executive which is empowered to block public scrutiny of state actions". The family of
Pat Finucane, a solicitor killed by
loyalist paramilitaries in
Belfast in suspicious circumstances, announced they would not be co-operating with a forthcoming inquiry into the events surrounding his death if it was held under the terms of the Act. The
Canadian judge
Peter Cory, who was commissioned by the
British and
Irish governments to investigate the possibility of state collusion in six high-profile murders, is also a critic. He recommended public inquiries into four of the killings, but has strongly condemned the legislation that quickly followed. In a letter read at a hearing of the
United States House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on Africa, Global Human Rights and International Operations Subcommittee while the legislation was pending, Cory stated: The chairman of the hearing, Representative
Chris Smith, declared that "the bill pending before the
British Parliament should be named the 'Public Inquiries Cover-up Bill'." Indeed, the act repealed the entirety of the
Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act 1921 which had allowed Parliament to vote on a resolution establishing a tribunal that had "all such powers, rights, and privileges as are vested in the High Court" and placed the power solely under the control of a Minister. == Notable inquiries ==