The game was a commercial success, selling over 1 million units in Europe. The game met with critical acclaim in Japan. In an interview around the time of the game's release in the region,
Shigeru Miyamoto said that "Konami's soccer game may be better than [Nintendo's N64] games. It looks really good."
Edge said that the Japanese import was "the most versatile and entertaining football game seen on any platform, and forms a strong addition to Nintendo's 64bit [sic] portfolio."
Next Generation said that the same Japanese import "goes farther than most titles in presenting a fantastic look and feel. Just make sure you have a few friends around to play it, otherwise you'll tire from 10-3 wins real quick." The most often cited strengths of the game included a variety of gameplay modes; the wide range of moves that the players can execute; the graceful, lifelike player animations; and the controls, particularly the tight responsiveness and strong implementation of the Nintendo 64 controller's analog joystick. However, most critics found it difficult to cover all of the game's positive elements. For example,
Next Generation commented, "Details like refs of varying skill, different weather conditions, real stadiums, and attitude give even more depth to a game that gets just about everything right." He later published a longer review which covered a few criticisms, such as the lack of a
FIFA license, but also commented more extensively on the game's strong attention to detail, and reemphasized that "As far as multiplayer games go, ISS64 has replaced
Mario Kart 64,
Star Fox 64 and
Wayne Gretzky as the ultimate gameplay experience." In its 1997 Editors' Choice Awards,
Electronic Gaming Monthly also named
International Superstar Soccer 64 "Sports Game of the Year" and a runner-up for "Nintendo 64 Game of the Year" (behind
GoldenEye 007).
Official Nintendo Magazine ranked it the 81st best game available on Nintendo platforms. The game won the award for "
Console Sports Game of the Year" at the
Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences'
inaugural Interactive Achievement Awards. == Legacy ==