Liston and Maguire state, "Contradictory media and sports reports exist regarding a team representing Ireland and/or Northern Ireland in 1934". Colonel Evan Hunter, of the 1934 organising committee, opposed an all-island team, stating that teams must have "the political style and title of the respective territories by which they are known within the British Empire". The English AAA invited the NIAAA to nominate competitors to represent Northern Ireland in
athletics,
cycling,
boxing, and
swimming; the NIAAA regulated only the former two sports, for which it nominated athletes who competed. The AAA separately invited the NACA nominate competitors to represent the Free State. The AAA's view conformed to a 1933 IAAF decision to require member associations to be delimited by political borders; the NACA had objected to that and would later be expelled from the IAAF as a consequence. NACA declined the invitation to the Empire Games, although it accepted a contemporaneous invitation to an international meeting in Scotland at which the NIAAA would field a separate Northern Ireland team.
Paddy Bermingham, a
Garda from
County Clare, was entered in the discus but did not compete, The
Commonwealth Games Federation (CGF) lists Bermingham under "Northern Ireland" in the entries, while a contemporary preview lists him as from the Irish Free State, as does Bob Phillips. The
Association of Track and Field Statisticians lists him as "Ireland" and "did not compete". The
Irish Amateur Swimming Association (IASA) refused to send teams for the Free State or Northern Ireland, pointing out that the bowling team was designated "Ireland" and that
Jersey competitors were on the England team. For similar reasons, the IASA boycotted
the 1948 Olympic swimming gala, also in London. The IABA in February declined to send a team, stating that the games were during its close season. In March,
William Grant asked in the
House of Commons of Northern Ireland whether, in the absence of IABA participation, the
Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) boxing club might represent Northern Ireland. In May, four IABA boxers who applied for exemption to participate in the Games got leave to do so. They were: Larry Scally (flyweight), T. Byrne (bantamweight), Jack Kennedy (welterweight), and
Jimmy Magill (middleweight). was in the RUC; as was William "Billy" Duncan, who won bronze at welterweight. Magill and Duncan's medals are credited to Northern Ireland. The
lawn bowls team was described as "Ireland" in reports of its selection, on the scoreboard, and in reports of its results. It was selected by the Irish Bowling Association, an all-island governing body, but the team members' clubs (Larne, Cavehill, and Shaftesbury ==Later games==