Herbert Crooker from
Midweek Pictorial opined that Colleen Moore does probably the best work of her career as the Irish Cinderella cutie and wears an array of gowns which brings forth squeals of joy and envy. My next medal is pinned on George K. Arthur, who furnishes comedy in the role of Mme. Lucy, although I fancy his heart was not in the role. Lloyd Hughes is a pleasing scion, and Charlie Murray and Kate Price supply a number of comedy moments. Film historian
Jeanine Basinger wrote "
Irene seems to exist on film only because of Colleen Moore. It should have been called Colleen. It's truly a star vehicle, presenting her front and center in every scene. The camera stays pinned to Moore while she makes faces, pantomimes, does imitations, and takes a series of comedy pratfalls; she is utterly distinctive, looking like no one else — the mark of a star."
Time Magazine said that "Miss Moore is, as ever, keenly attractive, and the picture is medium good entertainment." Film historian
Anthony Slide opined that "present-day gays looking for role models in silent films might feel shortchanged; obviously gay characters are strictly limited to camp and effeminate stereotypes like George Arthur as prissy Madame Lucy, the effeminate owner of a dress-making establishment. Arthur's comment to Colleen Moore, as the title character, that 'You walk almost like a man!' is met with the response, 'So do you!'" Queer film historian
Vito Russo observed that "Madame Lucy, given to severely tailored suits and lace hankies, is a whimsical creature described as a man living in a woman's world; he plays the snippy queen in a drag-like performance filled with extravagant gestures and eye popping; when he takes a first look at Irene, he exclaims 'As I live and hemstitch, she's impossible! Even I cannot make peach melba from a prune'." ==See also==