McCalla made her Broadway debut in January 2018, as
Jasmine in Disney's
Aladdin. She had previously originated the role in the first national tour. Later in 2018, McCalla originated the role of Alyssa Greene in
The Prom on Broadway. She had previously performed as an ensemble member in the show's Atlanta premiere in 2016. McCalla and co-star
Caitlin Kinnunen's kiss during their performance at the 2018 Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade made national news as the first LGBT kiss in the parade's history. McCalla appeared across the US performing beloved songs as part of the
Disney Princess — The Concert tour. McCalla replaced
Caroline Innerbichler as Maizy in
Shucked on
Broadway at the
Nederlander Theater in early September 2023. In 2024, she starred with
Grant Gustin in the
Broadway musical adaptation of the novel,
Water for Elephants. In February 2025, it was announced that McCalla would portray Elinor in the musical
Regency Girls, which is set to premiere on April 10, 2025. == Personal life ==