Reception to the first issue was mostly positive. Jenna Anderson of Comicbook praised the world-building and how
Isola’s characters are defined through their actions. Molly Barnewitz of
Comicsverse particularly praised Rook’s characterization. However,
David Pepose of
Newsarama felt the story was too decompressed and that its only selling point was Kerschl’s art. Karl Kerschl and MSassyK’s art received universal praise. The
Eisner-winning digital comics magazine
PanelxPanel selected
Isola as its feature comic for April 2018. This was particularly notable since
PanelxPanel normally selects comics with longer runs, specifically avoiding comics with only a single issue out. Editor Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou explained in his introduction that he had made an exception for
Isola #1 since it is markedly different from most other first issues, specifically that it was "more contemplative and less expository, but deeply interesting and worthwhile."
Awards ==References==