The song was covered several times following the appearance in
King of Jazz, including by
George Olsen and
Vincent Lopez. Other popular versions were by the
Regent Club Orchestra on
Brunswick Records, and
Ruth Etting.
Bing Crosby sang the song with Whiteman's orchestra in a performance at the
Seattle Civic Auditorium, which was broadcast nationwide live via the
Columbia Broadcasting System in April 1930.
Mel Tormé recorded it in 1946 in a then-contemporary 4/4 swing arrangement with his
Mel-Tones and
Sonny Burke and his orchestra on the
Musicraft Records label. In 1955, the song was recorded in its original waltz form by
Perry Como, and then further popularized by a 1956
Frank Sinatra recording, which, like the earlier Tormé recording, gave the song a 4/4 swing arrangement. Sinatra included it on his 1956 Capitol release ''
Songs for Swingin' Lovers!'', an album that featured arrangements by
Nelson Riddle. Biographer
John Frayn Turner writes: It Happened in Monterey'... had never sounded like that before or since". Biographer Spencer Leigh notes the "looseness of his phrasing in the second chorus". and also appeared on the original UK pressing of
Come Fly with Me as a replacement track for the banned "
On the Road to Mandalay".
Bing Crosby and
Rosemary Clooney included the song in their 1958 album
Fancy Meeting You Here with updated lyrics. ==In popular culture==