A contemporary review from 'Argus' in
The Literary Digest, 1935, declared: "It is clumsy, crude, and quite amateurish in its appearance. It merely happens that a great comedian appears in it and has a free hand in his brilliant clowning, with the result that defects become unimportant, and the film emerges as a comedy delight."
James Agee lauded the film: "The talkies brought one great comedian, the late, majestically lethargic W. C. Fields, who could not possibly have worked as well in silence; he was the toughest and most warmly human of all screen comedians, and ''It's a Gift'' and
The Bank Dick, fiendishly funny and incisive white-collar comedies, rank high among the best comedies (and best movies) ever made."
Leonard Maltin gave it four of four stars: "Beautiful comedy routines in one of the Great Man's unforgettable films."
Leslie Halliwell gave it two of four stars: "Roughly assembled comedy of disasters which happens to show the star more of less at his best... " As of January, 2023 the film has a reviewer rating of 94% on Rotten Tomatoes. In 2010, this film was selected for preservation in the United States
National Film Registry by the
Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". The film is recognized by
American Film Institute in: • 2000:
AFI's 100 Years...100 Laughs – #58 == See also ==