"It's Not Your Fault" is a
rock song at a length of three minutes and thirty seven seconds, written by the five members of New Found Glory, all of whom share credits for the music composition and the lyrics. The song is composed in the
A Major key and has a "moderate tempo" of 129
beats per minute. The band's primary
composer and guitarist
Chad Gilbert, notes that the song has "big, full
guitars and a
piano line that goes throughout. It's pretty anthemic, and Jordan's voice has never sounded better." Gilbert further explained that, "This one shows how we've changed. We're a band who have done different styles of songs every record. There's some really
metal riffs on
Catalyst that aren't on
Coming Home, and then this had some pianos. We're music fans, so we want every record to sound different". Lyrically, the song is about dealing with time apart in a relationship. The band's
lead vocalist Jordan Pundik has noted, "I want people to think it's about whatever they want, but for me, it's about when you're in love with someone and you're away from them and you have an argument or a fight and it's over the phone, so you can't console them." ==Critical reception==