Japanese reception The film saw mostly positive reception from critics and industry professionals on and around release.
Yoshikazu Yasuhiko said that the reason the film feels like something new is because it is not merely a montage of disjointed scenes, but a complete world depicted within 80 minutes. He also compared the art in the film to the
modernism in
Belladonna of Sadness, being beautiful but also dangerous.
Haruhiko Mikimoto expressed appreciation for the art direction, particularly having characters with color in front of monotone backgrounds, the use of silhouettes in the backgrounds, and the use of barely visible objects in the dark in backgrounds. He also said that Angel's Egg brought out the best merit of an OVA, which is letting the creator make what they want to make, and that he felt the quality of the film meant it would not be out of place in a movie theater.
Shoji Kokami had high praise for the film, saying that it is a "two-dimensional poem of images given form" that "should be valued as a pinnacle of the media of animation." Anime critic and producer also had high praise for the film, saying the apocalyptic setting, religious aspects, and lack of life in it both appeals to and bewilders fans of science fiction. He also contrasted the film with
Urusei Yatsura 2: Beautiful Dreamer and
Dallos, saying that while they were about giving meaning to a fictional world, it makes an abnormal world to give the characters meaning. The film has gained more critical acclaim from critics and industry professionals in later years, with people such as
Shoji Kawamori,
Ryu Mitsuse,
Hideo Osabe,
Takashi Murakami, and directors
Shunji Iwai and heaping praise on it.
Hayao Miyazaki was more critical of the film, and recounts that
Toru Horikoshi, who was a producer for
Nippon TV at the time, fell asleep watching the film, and that while
Michihiko Suwa of
Yomiuri TV approved it for a TV broadcast, he said that he did not understand the film. Miyazaki himself said regarding the film that he "appreciates the effort, but it is not something others would understand" and of Oshii "he goes on a one-way journey without thinking of how to get back". Oshii recounts that his mother said upon watching the film that nobody would watch his films anymore.
Western reception Western critics found the film confusing, citing its allegory, symbolism, and ending, as the reasons.
Helen McCarthy called it "an early masterpiece of symbolic film-making", stating that "its surreal beauty and slow pace created a Zen-like atmosphere, unlike any other anime". In his book
Horror and Science Fiction Film IV, Donald C Willis described the film as "a haunting, poetic melancholic science-fantasy film, and–for non-Japanese-speaking viewers at least–a very cryptic one." Willis also included the film in his list of most memorable films from 1987 to 1997. In an article in
Senses of Cinema on Oshii, Richard Suchenski stated that the film was Oshii's "purest distillation of both Oshii's visual mythology and his formal style". The review noted that "
Patlabor 2 is more sophisticated,
Ghost in the Shell is more important, and
Avalon is more mythically complex but the low-tech, hand-drawn ''Angel's Egg'' remains Oshii's most personal film." ==See also==