Cotter became a minister in the Church of Scotland, a path worn by the Scotland rugby union international
William Milne. From the Dundee Courier of 3 October 1934: DUNDEE MINISTER IN VACANCY VOTE Noted Rugby Player Appointed.Rev. James L. Cotter, assistant of Glasgow Cathedral, was last night elected minister of the church and parish of Troon. He received 297 votes against 246 recorded in favour of Rev. McIntosh Mowat, of St John's Cross, Dundee. There were 21 votes against both of them. Mr Cotter is a noted rugby player. He turns out for Hillhead at full-back, and played stand-off for Scotland against England and Ireland last season. He is 28 years of age. Mr Mowat said to the
Courier and Advertiser last night that he did not apply for Troon Church. Representatives of the church heard him while he was holidaying in Ayr, after which he was nominated. Mr Mowat agreed on condition that he was sole nominee. Recently when two names were put forward Mr Mowat desired to withdraw, but that was not done. A biography of his life known as
Tackling Life: A Biography of the Rev. James Logan Cotter by Logan Cotter was published in 2000. ==References==