Billboard described "James Dean" as "good solid rocker" with "fine vocal harmonies" whose instrumentation is reminiscent of
Jackson Browne's 1973 song "
Redneck Friend," on which Eagles guitarist
Glenn Frey provided backup vocals.
Cash Box said that this is "one of the best rockers to come around in years", that "lyrically, the tribute to the legendary film star is letter perfect", and that "musically, well, just try to keep from dancing here."
Record World said that the "legendary screen idol of the '50s still stands tall as a rebellious figure, worthy of the contemporary missive that these men definitely deliver with all due cause, speed and prowess."
Ultimate Classic Rock critic Sterling Whitaker rated it as the Eagles 8th most underrated song.
Classic Rock critic Paul Elliott described it as a "ghastly homage." ==Personnel==