Known familiarly as
Jim Brady or
James T., he was admitted to the New York Bar in either 1835 or 1836, when he was about twenty years old. His first case was an insurance proceeding, where he opposed the prominent lawyer,
Charles O'Conor. The plaintiff staked a claim for insurance money from a property allegedly burned down by a fire. Though Brady lost that case, his proficiency for law and oration was immediately noted. O'Conor would later ask Brady to assist in the defense of
Jefferson Davis. Brady received his first taste of legal notoriety during the
Goodyear v. Day patent case, where he worked under
Daniel Webster and delivered the
opening arguments for the plaintiff. Nevertheless, Brady is best known for his work as a criminal lawyer. In the quarter century preceding his death, he was involved in nearly every notable criminal proceeding in the Eastern United States. Brady also defended
Lew Baker at his trial for the murder of the infamous
William "Bill the Butcher" Poole, whom Baker shot to death in 1855 at Stanwix Hall, a bar on
Broadway in
Manhattan. Over his career, Brady tried 52 criminal cases and lost only one, the case of
Confederate privateer John Yates Beall. It is said that he never lost a case in which he was before a jury for more than a week; by that time they saw everything with his eyes A fellow attorney called Brady, "Lord of the tear and the laugh." Brady was a fine orator, known for his in-depth preparation, but it was also noted that due to his comprehensive grasp of the law, that when called in for consultation, he could, having heard only the opening arguments, present a concise, successful summation. Brady was particularly successful in criminal cases, in which he usually appeared for the defense, frequently without fee. In 1843 he was made the interim
district attorney for New York County. Two years later, Brady was appointed the city's
corporation counsel, a position in which he served two terms, each term lasting for a year. In 1850 Brady ran for, but was not elected to, the position of
Attorney General of New York. Brady was on
John C. Breckinridge and
Joseph Lane's 1860 Democratic ticket for
Governor of New York. When the
American Civil War began, Brady switched sides and became an ardent supporter of
Abraham Lincoln and his
Republican Party. He deeply disdained Southern politics and policy, however, when the government proposed to try
Jefferson Davis for treason, Brady was asked to join the defense, and did so without compensation. Brady enjoyed the New York social and literary society, frequently dining at
Delmonico's and occasionally contributing pieces to
The Knickerbocker. A friend and patron of New Jersey artist
William Ranney, in December 1858, Brady gave a lecture on American art to help defray expenses of the Ranney Exhibition, organized on behalf of Ranney's widow and children. == Personal life and death ==