The baseball team won the Central Jersey Group I state sectional title in 1960 and 1961. The boys' soccer team was won the Group I championship playoffs in 1961 (defeating
Blairstown High School in the tournament final), 1962 (vs. Blairstown), 1963 (declared as state champion), 1966 (as co-champion with
Harrison High School), 1971 (vs. Harrison), 1972 (as co-champion with Harrison) and 1973 (vs.
Chatham Borough High School). A 2–1 overtime win against Blairstown in the Group I final gave the team a 14–2 record for the season. The team ran their record to 11–1 after winning the 1962 Group I state title with a 2–1 overtime win against Blairstown in the championship game played at
Pingry School. The 1966 team finished the season at 12–0–4 after coming back to tie Harrison 1–1 in the Group I championship game. The 1972 team finished the season with a 15–0–1 record after being declared as the Group I title co-champion with Harrison following a 1–1 tie after double overtime in the tournament final played at
Fairleigh Dickinson University. ==Notable alumni==