Main traditions Sakhi Mahal Pehle Ki Sakhi Mahal Pehle Ki was discovered by Piar Singh and
McLeod, but remained unexamined and published until 2014 when Dr. S.S. Padam found multiple different manuscripts of the text across Punjabi universities and published them with examination. The text is now considered the oldest of the Janamsakhi tradition and the root source for the other Janamsakhis. Sakhi Mahal Pehle Ki has been dated to 1570-1574, during the last few years of Guru Amar Das's guruship. Scholars consider this Janamsakhi to have been used by authors of other traditions. The manuscript he discovered dated to 1701 but
Harbans Singh believes the tradition may date back to the mid-17th century but unlikely to originate earlier than that period. There are reasons to doubt this contention as Guru Angad, who is said to have commissioned the work and was also a close companion of the Guru in his later years, was, according to Bala's own admission, ignorant of the existence of Bala. The oldest accepted manuscript of the Bala
janamsakhi was written by Gorakh Das in 1658, but the actual date is believed to be earlier. It is generally believed this
janamsakhi were written by
Hindalis as in a number of stories Guru Nanak praises Baba Hindal. Some are of the belief that this is a contemporary work and was later edited by the Hindalis. One of the people who subscribed to this belief was Santhok Singh the author of the famed
Suraj Granth. Santhok Singh wrote Nanak Parkash based on the Bala
janamsakhi with the goal of removing parts he believed were edited and added by the Hindalis. Dr. Trilochan Singh counters some of the points raised against the Bala
janamsakhi by stating that
Mehma Parkash and Mani Singh's
janamsakhi both mention Bhai Bala. Bala is further mentioned in
Suchak Prasang Guru Ka by Bhai Behlo written during
Guru Arjan Dev's time. Bhai Behlo says, “Bala discarded his body there, At the holy city of
Khadaur, Angad, the master, performed the rites, Graciously with his own two hands.” He also raises the point that Bhai Bala's family is still living in
Nankana Sahib and that Bala's
samadhi exists in
Khadaur. Singh claims the
janamsakhi was written by Bhai Bala and is mostly authentic but was edited and changed by anti-Sikh sects. The work is an expansion of the first
Vaar of
Varan Bhai Gurdas. It shows influence from the Bhai Bala tradition.
Minor traditions Various other more minor and obscure
janamsakhi traditions are known. One such tradition is that of the B40, which contains influences of both the Puratan and Miharvan traditions.
Women's oral Janamsakhis Aside from literary Janamsakhis, there also exists a Janamsakhi tradition passed down orally by
Sikh women which provide more information about the lives of girls and women during the period of the first Sikh guru. Particular emphasis and focus is placed on prominent Sikh female figures, their influences, and impact, such as
Mata Tripta,
Bebe Nanaki, and
Mata Sulakhni. Khushwant Singh similarly expresses his doubts, but extensively relied on the Janamsakhis in his
A History of the Sikhs. Macauliffe interspersed his translation of the Sikh scripture between
Janamsakhis-derived mythical history of the Sikh Gurus. Post-colonial scholarship has questioned Macauliffe's reliance on
janamsakhis as "uncritical" and "dubious", though one that pleased the Sikh community. Out of 124
sakhis, he classified 37 as "probable" or "established," and 28 as "possible." Specifically looking for details "of importance" as it "angered many Sikhs" who saw him as "removing the vibrant life and message of their Guru from these texts," using incompatible Christian heuristic methodologies comparable to the
Higher Criticism of the Gospels, == Janamsakhis of other Sikh gurus ==