Jane Doe received wider acclaim than Converge's previous albums, with
Terrorizer naming it their Album of the Year. Christopher Dare of
Pitchfork Media awarded the album with a rating of 7.7 out of 10, deeming it "so full of intelligence, skill and intensity that it's simply masterful." Blake Butler of
Allmusic stated that Converge "put the final sealing blow on their status as a legend in the world of
metallic hardcore" with the album, calling it "an experience -- an encyclopedic envelopment of so much at once." In 2007,
Decibel magazine placed the album at number 35 on its "Decibel Hall of Fame" list, and later named it the best album of the 2000s. Sputnikmusic placed
Jane Doe at number one on its list of the best albums of the 2000s, and
Loudwire placed the album at number ten on its list of the 11 best metal albums of the 2000s. In March 2023,
Rolling Stone ranked the album's opening track, "Concubine", at number seventy-eight on their list of "The 100 Greatest Heavy Metal Songs of All Time". The album has exerted considerable influence in extreme music circles and attained a
cult following. Japanese band
Heaven in Her Arms are named after the song of the same name.
NME wrote in 2018: "The spasmodic, guttural twists and turns of Converge’s bile-packed, visceral take on hardcore are yet to be rivalled, 17 years after ‘Jane Doe’’s release."
Revolver wrote in 2019: "
Jane Doe is the record that launched a million T-shirts and tattoos with its iconic cover, but it’s the lasting impact on heavy music and the thousands of rip-off acts that truly speak to its legacy. Helping to shape the landscape of American heavy metal for the next decade and beyond, this metalcore masterpiece deservedly remains Converge’s most beloved record, as well as a genre favorite, even now, 18 years after its bombastic debut." In 2021, Eli Enis of
Revolver included the song "Concubine" in his list of the "15 Greatest Album-Opening Songs in Metal". In 2025, Rolli of
Loudwire said it was the band's best album and wrote: "To the uninitiated,
Jane Doe sounds like an impenetrable wall of bloodcurdling hardcore. To faithful Converge fans, it also sounds like an impenetrable wall of bloodcurdling hardcore — but in a complimentary way. [...]
Jane Doe has worked its tendrils into various strains of metalcore and inspired legions of imitators, though none can hold a candle to its destructive onslaught."
Accolades A "—" denotes the publication's list is in no particular order, and
Jane Doe did not rank numerically. ==Track listing==