Initial response Even before the release of
The Phantom Menace, Jar Jar Binks became the subject of significant media and popular attention. After the film's release, Binks became symbolic of what many reviewers such as Brent Staples (
The New York Times), David Edelstein (
Slate), and Eric Harrison (
Los Angeles Times) In 2018, Best said that the widespread criticism of his character negatively impacted his career and led him to
consider suicide. After these comments were reported by
The Guardian, fans expressed their support for Best on social media, with many, including
Frank Oz (the actor portraying
Yoda), denouncing the vitriol Best experienced. Oz wrote, "I LOVED Jar Jar Binks. I know I'll get raked over the coals for saying that but I just will never understand the harshness of people's dislike of him. I do character work. He is a GREAT character!" Legal scholar
Patricia J. Williams argued that many aspects of Jar Jar Binks' characterization were reminiscent of the
blackface archetypes in
minstrel shows, while academic Paul J. Ford suggested the character is a "laid-back clown character" which utilized stereotypes of
Afro-Caribbean people. Lucasfilm denied any racist intention in the character's creation. George Lucas further stated that "those criticisms are made by people who've obviously never met a Jamaican ... How in the world could you take an orange
amphibian and say that he's a Jamaican?". Ahmed Best also rejected such claims, stating that "Jar Jar has nothing to do with the Caribbean".
Speculations of villainy On December 19, 2010,
Adult Swim released
Robot Chicken: Star Wars Episode III, an animated comedy special parody of
Star Wars. In the first sketch, titled ''The Emperor's Back
, Emperor Palpatine feels remorse for his actions and calls Jar Jar, voiced by Ahmed Best himself, on the telephone, apologizing to him for manipulating him into granting Palpatine emergency powers in the senate during Attack of the Clones. Jar Jar pretends to accept this apology, feigning innocence, but after he hangs up he reveals that he was in fact a Sith Lord who only pretended to be manipulated by Palpatine and actually manipulated Palpatine himself. This sketch was in reference to a popular in-joke among Star Wars'' fans. Five years later, in late October 2015, a
Reddit user by the name of "Lumpawarroo" (the name of Chewbacca's son) published a detailed theory speculating that Jar Jar was originally written as a major
antagonist of the series, a manipulative, prominent collaborator of
Palpatine, before being written off from his major villain's role due to the character's negative reception. This theory was related to an earlier interview with actor Ahmed Best in
/r/IAmA, where he claimed that Jar Jar had been displaced from the story's main focus due to the backlash, implying at the same time that the hate received by the character was not entirely unintentional. The post quickly became popular and received significant media coverage internationally by independent bloggers and major news outlets like
The Guardian,
The Washington Post, and
The New York Times, which included analysis of his actions in
The Phantom Menace. Journalist Andrew Street from
The Guardian called it a "classic twist", comparing it to
Yoda's role in
The Empire Strikes Back, while Matt Hickey from
Forbes went to the extent of contacting
George Lucas about the question, but received no answer. In response to the speculations, Best
tweeted, "I will say this, it feels really good when the hidden meaning behind the work is seen. No matter how long it takes," apparently confirming the theory. Some months later, he expanded upon his tweet in a
YouTube interview, stating, "there is a lot about [the theory] that is true, there are some things about it that are not true ... Could Jar Jar have evolved into that? I think the answer is yes. Because of the backlash, and rightfully so, Lucasfilm backed off of Jar Jar a lot, but a lot of the influence that I put into the character mirrored a lot of what was already in the
Star Wars universe." Best concluded only Lucas could unveil the actual role of Binks, yet he also claimed that a deleted scene from
Attack of the Clones would have still shown Palpatine darkly confiding his plans about the Empire to Jar Jar.
J. J. Abrams, who directed two installments of the franchise's
sequel trilogy after its buyout by
Disney, personally approved of the theory about the villainous Jar Jar. He described Lumpawarroo's argumentation as an "unbelievably lengthy analysis, in a very seriously thought-out way, as to why it's obviously true he's [evil]." In 2019, when questioned about it, Best stated again only Lucas could answer, but he confirmed the theorists' idea of Jar Jar's antics being actually a disguised fighting style akin to
drunken boxing, revealing that he based his performance on
Jackie Chan's role in the 1978 film
Drunken Master. He said, "the Darth Jar Jar theory caught it - caught it. I never thought anybody would see that". The Darth Jar Jar theory is referenced in the animated miniseries
Lego Star Wars: Rebuild the Galaxy, in which a Jedi relic accidentally rewrites reality and turns Jar Jar (reprised by Best) into a Sith Lord. In 2025, Jar Jar was added to
Fortnite Battle Royale as part of the
Star Wars-themed "Galactic Battle" season, where he is depicted as a Sith Lord capable of using Force Lightning.
Character reassessment Since the release of
The Phantom Menace, cast and crew who have worked on the
Star Wars films and viewers have defended Jar Jar Binks (as well as Ahmed Best). In April 2019, during the annual
Star Wars Celebration event ahead of the 20th anniversary panel for
The Phantom Menace, George Lucas named Jar Jar as his favorite
Star Wars character. In an interview with
IGN during the premiere of
The Force Awakens, Yoda's performer
Frank Oz stated that Jar Jar Binks is his favorite character: "I love Jar Jar Binks. I swear to god I do ... When I saw that script I thought he was a fantastic character and I don't know what the heck happened ... I thought he was fantastic; he was hysterical. He reminded me of
Abbott and Costello." Actor
Liam Neeson praised Ahmed Best for his portrayal of Jar Jar: "I know a lot of fans and critics didn't like it. [Best] received a lot of criticism, to the point where it really hurt his career. And I have to say that when he was making that movie, with Best as Jar Jar Binks and with Ewan McGregor as young Obi-Wan Kenobi, he was probably one of the funniest and most talented guys I've ever worked with. I remember calling ... my old ex-agent ... and saying, 'Listen, I think I just worked with the new
Eddie Murphy.' And I still believe it." During the 20th anniversary of
The Phantom Menace, many members of the prequel production team have defended the character and appreciated the public's acceptance at the
Star Wars Celebration panel. Visual effects supervisor
John Knoll reflected: "Well, I think it's good to see [his newfound popularity], because I think George took a lot of the criticism pretty harshly. It was kind of painful for me to see how cruel people were about it and how personally George took it. I think the movies didn't deserve as much hate as they received. It hurt me to see how much George took those things." He also said, "I thought [the Star Wars Celebration panel] was great, especially the warm reaction there was to Ahmed. I know he took all the vicious comments people had about Jar Jar very hard. That's not his fault, he didn't write that character. He's an actor who did a really good job and worked hard to get it right. Seeing the really warm reaction of the crowd made me feel ... It was moving." In an interview with
Europa Press during the premiere of
Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, a journalist asked actress
Felicity Jones who she would like to receive a gift from if she were in the
Star Wars galaxy at Christmas time and she said either Jar Jar or C-3P0. Following the reassessment of Jar Jar (as well as the reappraisal of the prequel trilogy), C-3PO actor
Anthony Daniels reflected in his memoirs that "the years have been kinder to this, the first Prequel. Many, who were young at the time, still hold it, and Jar Jar Binks as their dearest memory of the Saga." Best was moved by people's appreciation for Jar Jar: "It was definitely the kids. I had to start looking at Jar Jar through their eyes, and that's what made me smile again. Now those kids, they are between 20 and 30 years old. They have a different perspective on
The Phantom Menace.
The Phantom Menace, for them, is their
Star Wars.
[Episodes] IV,
V and
VI, that's their parents'
Star Wars, and
VII,
VIII and
IX, that's their children's
Star Wars. But the prequels, that's theirs, and they defend the prequels. So I see the same thing. I see the resurgence of
The Phantom Menace." He then talked about his experience of going to
Star Wars Celebration: "To be very honest, I was very afraid to go to Celebration. Every time I'm in a
Star Wars setting, I spend most of my time defending our work and defending Jar Jar. And I just don't want to do that anymore. So I was very reluctant to come to Celebration because of that, and I have to say, I was pleasantly surprised. It wasn't the case at all. I just felt nothing but love and respect and admiration for the work we did. I couldn't have been more proud and I couldn't have been happier. I wish George was there because I think we're at a time right now where we have to stand in that work. We have to say, "We did it," and step into that in a very proud way, because it stands the test of time." ==Notes==