Bologna Phoenix McDonagh played for the Bologna Phoenix in the
Italian Football League during the 1997 season. The Phoenix advanced to the Italian Super Bowl, while McDonagh was voted as league and team MVP.
Green Bay Bombers McDonagh played for the
Green Bay Bombers of the
Professional Indoor Football League in 1998. He was named Offensive Player of the Year and an All-Star after throwing for 56 touchdowns.
Madison Mad Dogs McDonagh played for the
Madison Mad Dogs of the
Indoor Football League in 2000. He earned All-League honors while helping his team to an 11–6 record. In defeat of the
Billings Thunderbolts, he completed 18 of 37 passes for 172 yards and 5 touchdowns. In a victory against the
Minnesota Purple Rage, McDonagh completed 15 of 23 passes for 4 touchdowns and 199 yards.
New Jersey/Las Vegas Gladiators McDonagh signed with the
New Jersey Gladiators in November 2001.
Colorado Crush McDonagh signed with the
Colorado Crush in November 2003. He was released by the Crush on January 29, 2004.
Columbus Destroyers McDonagh was signed by the
Columbus Destroyers' practice squad on April 2, 2004. He was promoted to the active roster on April 6, 2004.
AFL statistics Stats from ArenaFan: ==References==