A tall octagonal wooden
fire lookout tower was the first building on the site, built circa 1833, located in the center of the merchants' sheds at the Jefferson Market that had been established at this site in 1832 and named for the
late President. Court sessions were held in the Jefferson Assembly Rooms that rose above the market sheds. The wood tower and the market structures were torn down by the city to build a new courthouse, the adjacent
Jefferson Market Prison building that stood on the corner of West 10th Street and Greenwich Avenue and new coordinated market housing (built in 1883). Of the carefully massed eclectic and picturesque group, only the former Courthouse now remains. The commission for the new courthouse went to the firm of Vaux and Withers, but as
Calvert Vaux was busy with the
American Museum of Natural History and the
Metropolitan Museum of Art, the design fell to his partner, the English-born
Frederick Clarke Withers. Withers came from the same background as Vaux, so it is not unusual that his
High Victorian Gothic design was similar in some respects to the "
Ruskinian Gothic" aesthetic of Vaux's early buildings, such as in its polychrome materials – red brick, black stone, white granite, yellow
sandstone trim and variegated roof slates. Reasoning that a building with a clock tower was going to look like a church no matter what he did, Withers decided to add church-like touches with non-religious content, such as the
tympanum which shows a scene from
The Merchant of Venice instead of the usual scene of Christ sitting in judgment or other ecclesiastical subject matter. The building also features stained glass windows and a fountain decorated with birds and animals. The courthouse was completed in 1877, and in 1885 a panel of American architects sponsored by
American Architect and Building News voted it the fifth most beautiful building in America. in front of it. Photograph by
Berenice Abbott (1935) ==Use and reuse==