In 2019, Keitel starred in the world premiere of
Martin Moran's play
Theo at
Two River Theater. She also starred in
Miller & Son (2019), which won the
BAFTA Student Film Award and gold medal for "Best Narrative" (Domestic) at the 2019
Student Academy Awards. Keitel played the leading role in the 2020 MadRiver Pictures sci-fi series,
Forever Alone. Keitel has performed in drag under the stage name Peroxide, As Peroxide Femanon, she has appeared in
Logo TV's
Fill In The Blank docuseries and in
Sasha Velour's NYFW SS19 collaboration with
Opening Ceremony. Beginning in 2020, Keitel starred as Jerrie Kennedy in the
David E. Kelley-created crime thriller
Big Sky, which made her one of the first non-binary actors to play a non-binary series regular on primetime television. In 2022, she appeared in an episode of
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, playing a non-binary villain. In an interview, she said of the role: "I understand that queer people have had a really long and complicated history with TV and film, and they’ve been very mistreated in the media....That being said, I think it’s high time we let queer people be villains, you know?" ==Awards and accolades==